Jump to content

TheIrishman

Forum Game Masters
  • Posts

    2,439
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    9
  • Donations

    0.00 USD 

Posts posted by TheIrishman

  1. Just now, Jeod said:

    You don't even know what timezone she's referring to, and why does PM timing matter? Order of resolution comes after everyone has sent in actions before the deadline, not on a PM-by-PM basis. It's basic GMing 101.

    I'm not familiar, I thought it was by whoever sent the action first would have it resolved first. Like how FRAYDO was conquered before he was killed.

  2. Just now, OrangeP47 said:

    Also, we need to consider this:  When we catch a rounder, their investigation targets die....

    1 minute ago, Jeod said:

    Correct. There's a conflict of interest when it comes to lynching a potential Rounder if they've targeted you already. If you want to win as a town, then you need to have the balls to accept death if it comes down to that.

    Are you guys so sure about that? Only one member of the Organization can kill at a time (and yes, I have a tab open to the rules at all times to double check).

    On 5/25/2017 at 7:16 PM, Category 5 Hurricane said:

    If the player flips as the active Rounder (currently that would be Rounder #1), all players that the killer targeted are immediately and retroactively killed and role determined based on chances at the time of death.

    Which means we have to lynch the other Rounder, presumably Rounder #2 first. If s/he dies first, then everyone will stay alive while we search for the last member of the organization.

  3. Of the 5 targets

    Kmod has been decently active.

    Last game Nod was pretty inactive and almost won commonly citing his inactivity as an excuse.

    Chopbam has been pretty distant

    KY also has been pretty inactive

    Misa seems to follow suit, but she's also new. Most new people hang back until they get a feel for things, or at least that's what I did.

    Just now, OrangeP47 said:

    Why exactly are we linking FGLs to rounders again?

    It's Jeod's hypothesis. I don't think it's true. It's more likely that the limit is only 1 for people to become part of a FGL.

    From the video and from the explanation of the game, everything seems to follow chances. Your organization chance wouldn't matter if it was derived purely from who you targeted. Even for only the first day, it seems silly.

    Also Orange already confirmed his FGL with Mojo.

  4. 1 minute ago, Chaos_Knight said:

    What's the point of it though? 3rd person can be both alive or dead, and time machine would still become available to use.

    Vaguely forgot about that. 

    Just now, Jeod said:

    Well, if she is indeed a Rounder, then she can do the same thing I asked Choppy to do if he was one: come out and say it, out the partner, and RNGUpa into another alignment.

    As sad as it is, two players are Rounders today and our goal is to find them. Such is mafia.

    On 5/25/2017 at 7:16 PM, Category 5 Hurricane said:

    Players in this doc will be kept anonymous, as Time Machine use may change who is on the SERN Team. Reveal yourselves at your own risk.

    Maybe, but only if the other partner revealed themselves.

    And just to help confirm this mess, Misa, what specific time did you send your PM?

  5. 2 minutes ago, Jeod said:

    Until then, the only thing I'm getting is that a bunch of you are putting your heads in the sand just because Jeod's name is attached to the hypothesis.

    I only know you as a good GM..

    For why I believe she's not in a FGL, I was just explaining it away to have it play out better in my head rather than just saying that there could be a limit of 1 person.

    Second possibility, I agree, absurd.

    The third one, not as much as I initially thought. Don't you need 3 members to get the time machine? She could be distracting us away from which group has a time machine already.

  6. So on the plus side guys, it appears that 2 people will be marked as the Organization and they can be changed each Day. The reason why I think it's Day instead phase is because the temporary Rounder Doc is closed during nights.

    Jeod, I'm doubtful on people meeting being the requirement for becoming a Rounder. If that's the case, that means that 2 people have to target the same person every night to become a Rounder. But that causes a problem, which comes first, becoming Rounders or making a Future Gadget Lab? Or do they do both? If that's the case there must be at least 5 FGLs...but can Chopbam or yourself even be a part of 2 FGLs at the same time? I'm don't think so. It also means that if two people don't investigate the same person, that there's to Organization to fight for the next Day.

    I think the most likely situation is that when first two people visit the same person, they form FGL then leave, causing the next person to be unable to form a FGL. If that's the case, that means if 4 people visit the same person, it'll create 2 different labs in chronological order.

    The second possibility is that Misa did meet you guys and formed a FGL, but this isn't very likely with how much you're hounding her.

    So my third thought is that Misa could've visited someone else and formed a FGL with another group. If that's the case, there'd be a 5th FGL or one of the other 3 has a third member. But I don't think there's any point in lying about it.

  7. 4 minutes ago, Jeod said:

    Learn to read guys, and learn to scumread. Misa is our best bet over Nodlied.

    I don't get it Jeod. How does that increase the chances of Misa being part of the Organization? If anything, it just confirmed that there is a rounder doc even for temporary Organization members and that it's closed during the night.

    And her response just reminds me of myself when Chop was targeting me last game. But maybe it's because I'm also new so I can vaguely relate.

  8. 1 minute ago, OrangeP47 said:

    When I get my internet back (rural internet clogged by driver download) I'll go back and check. I agree, it doesn't make much sense, but that's what I thought at the time. Maybe to leave notes. But regardless, the alternative then is why aren't you all discussing a confirmed rounder doc we just don't know about as compared to a possible rounder doc?

    I'm a bit confused, I don't think I was ever talking about a possible rounder doc. For the reason previously stated, I don't think there's any chance that one doesn't already exist. To me, it's already confirmed.

  9. Just now, kamuixmod said:

    The main problem though is that nobody is going to die until one of the rounders die to confirm their idendity or a confirmed reading steiner finds said scum. Whichever comes first.

    The moment a reading steiner confirms someone from the organization, deaths should happen at the same time from what I understand.

  10. Just now, OrangeP47 said:

    It also implied though that the rounder doc only happens once someone is assuredly a rounder. Or maybe I read it wrong. But I'm pretty sure fluxy rounders don't get it?

    Why wouldn't they? You're only locked in when you're dead or there's no other possibility. If you only gain access when you're locked in, you can't use it since you're most likely dead.

  11. 16 minutes ago, OrangeP47 said:

    Well it was said the organization team can change... so it has to happen somehow... probably through use of the time machine though and changing people's actions.

    I think the Organization is in a constant state of flux while we play the game. Like how it said in the PM, if you're determined to die Night 0, you will be Vanilla Town. But it also clarified what you would be on Day 1 if you were lynched, even if it's still Vanilla Town. So that means each phase your chances for a role changes. Or at least each Day since D0 would have the same stats as N0. It's the same with have reading steiner, it's uncertain who has until they die or there's no other possibility. And when they're locked in, they're locked in no matter what.

  12. Actually, once you're confirmed as part of the Organization, I don't think there's any getting out of it, even with a time machine. Because the moment you're confirmed, it means that you were actually part of the Organization the entire time, so no matter which day you go to, they were part of the Organization. The most you might be able to do is kill the Organization member at an earlier date.

  13. 7 minutes ago, OrangeP47 said:

    I think rounder docs don't happen until people are 'locked in' as rounders, though, but the thing is that due to time travel and waveform collapsing they can shift that way so nobody is ever truly 'locked in' because of the alternative world lines.

    That's true for everything but reading steiner. Reading steiner allows the user to remember everything across different world lines, so once you're found to have that, it'll never change.

×
×
  • Create New...