Jump to content


Forum Game Masters
  • Posts

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

  • Donations

    0.00 USD 

Posts posted by TheIrishman

  1. 47 minutes ago, ChopBam said:

    I was kind of okay leaving this to RNG. Honestly the result surprises me slightly.

    8 minutes ago, FRAYDO said:

    Huh. I practically ignored the thread because I was confident Irish was scum and liked seeing Shade and Category 5 hash it out.

    RcTnk99 - Twitch


    33 minutes ago, TheIrishman said:

    Oh, I thought tomorrow was hammer. Fuck.

    I know I was dumb for missing hammer, but y'all except [redacted] were even dumber. Good luck.

  2. I know ChopBam has no abilities or items which is basically the whole point of my role. And the scrambler sounds like the only item that could've countered me. My role would be dumb and borderline pointless if a zero read on both things gave him the option to still be scum. And with Jeod having no apparent abiliity then the last remaining scum has to have one, orherwise the balance is bad.

    If I wanted to be dishonest to keep things simple, I would've just claimed a standard cop.

    Cat5 and Shade are my current suspects. I'm more suspicious of Shade but I'd rather lynch Cat5 so we can jail shade during the night phase. If there's a nk, feel free to lynch me for being wrong. There'd still be FRAYDO, Retal, Chop, Louis, and Shade, minus one, so 4 town vs 1 scum should still be an easy victory as FRAYDO would the last possible culprit (Shade being jailed, Retal being jailed, and Chop being cleared).

  3. Okay, that's not what I expected. I had to use them on the same person because the item wouldn't let me target anyone with it, just to activate it as I visited. Otherwise I would've picked you and Retal. Passing it to a vanilla player would've made it useless. I was pretty confident that we aren't able to target players with items and that's why Shade was saying vanilla town can't have items. I expected it to say so in all vanilla PM's with Shade's certainty of the statement and nobody debating it and since there's no point in them having an item like mine.

  4. 1 hour ago, ChopBam said:

    You indicated at the start of the day that you used an item on me, and also said I was cleared as town (without claiming a separate ability). It's easy to infer a link between the item and the investigative result, being that you used them both on the same person and only directly claimed the item rather than a full ability.

    Before this, Shade. How are you certain vanilla town can't have items?

  5. Fraydo and shade claimed vanilla.

    ChopBam is vanilla town.

    Cat5 is a bus with some item most likely

    Louis is a jailor with BP

    I'm a cop with an item search

    Jeod had a scrambler and a seeker drone. Pretty sure the scrambler was to prevent investigations.

    And I agree, that's why FRAYDO wasn't a suspect before. Although I also feel Shade helped quite a bit in getting Jeod. I kinda want to No Lynch so I can investigate first but I'd probably also die first.

  6. Full disclosure since it's gone. My Sonar Probe could sense if a player had any items, but said it had a sensitivity for things producing a Holtzman Field.

    The problem with Louis being scum is it means that Cat5 is telling the truth about his ability. So the only way for me to be jailed is if she targeted Jeod. And Cat5 is lying about his ability, the only answer is that he's a jailor too.

    I've thought a lot more about the possibilities and I think there is a roleblocker scum and they targeted me while Jeod tried to NK me. So he was RB'd by his teammate. Louis pressured him right away, like she knew something which probably made him feel nervous. Shade then suggested Jeod was roleblocked which made him feel more pressure so Jeod claimed he passed one of his items. It's like he wanted everyone to know he did something and wasn't RB'd. He even asserted that everyone shouldn't hop on a bandwagon if a player was RB'd. Then immediately backtracked only after Louis said she roleblocked him. Now he's caught in a lie, because he just said he passed an item and is being told he was roleblocked. He has no other choice than to admit that he "attempted" to pass an item, admit to being roleblocked and hope for the best because he "knows" his teammate roleblocked me. That's what I've gathered so far.

    Louis is Town because she targeted Jeod.

    ChopBam is Town because I checked him

    Retaliation is Town because he was jailed as there was an attempt on Louis' life.

    I'm Town because I'm the cop role.

    Cat5 would have to be a jailor or had Jeod target himself for the NK which seems too unlikely.

    So the only real suspects left are Shade and FRAYDO. I don't like how the suspects have shifted completely because it means I had a bad read before. 

  7. If cat5 is scum, it would've required Jeod to target himself as the nightkill, have it swapped with me and had the NK fail and Jeod claimed RB in confusion. Feels a bit forced because I don't think Jeod would've slipped so easily and I would've been an easy push. But yeah, Cat5's claim might help. He'll be on in an hour or two. 

    FRAYDO, I didn't leave an item, it was just flavor. And my investigative role didn't find out anything N1 because I was jailed.


  • Create New...