Jump to content

Sunflower

Forum Game Masters
  • Posts

    1,544
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    20
  • Donations

    0.00 USD 

Posts posted by Sunflower

  1. I thought it was pretty fun from a whodunnit perspective. Everything was so mysterious that even though it seemed like the answer was obvious, I kept rethinking and wondering if something crazy was going on. Tho it was too bad about all the unlucky fails that kept me from monkeying around like I'd hoped.

  2. 8 minutes ago, Retaliation said:

    Louis did kind of supercharge his role lol. I'm pretty sure Sunflower could have dealt with it as well.

    I think I'd rather have a role like Orange's rather than that Frankenstein one.

    Maybe. My throw action could destroy items, but it sounded like it wasn't 100%

    Monkey See, Monkey Take meant I took items from players I visited btw. If they didn't have an item, I'd pick up some rubble instead. And I could throw the rubble at people! That was how I knew I didn't visit anyone.

  3. 4 minutes ago, Retaliation said:

    Maybe we should no lynch again so KY has to remain alone in the dead doc?

    I feel like we just need info right now. Even if that means I take the hit in the random roll, I'm fine with that. I want whoever lame-o is ruining my King Kong fun to get caught.

  4. 2 minutes ago, Retaliation said:

    I feel like I've entered crazy town where everything I've done and will do is interpreted in the scummiest way possible. 

    Granted it's honestly not all that different than how Orange was treating me between D1 and D2.

    Join the club. :p

  5. 4 minutes ago, FRAYDO said:

    If I entertain the thought of a KY/Retal team (wow this tinfoil hat is fashionable!) I can justify the bus in seeing no earthly way for KY to have talked his way out of his predicament. Although Retal did make use of KY's husk for an action, now I wonder if even he knew the action was downgraded from a daykill to a voteblock when he targeted Cat5 earlier.

    Yeah if KY had said he used an item on ILTS, I could see maaaaaybe them being able to push the lynch onto me if things went in their favor. But since he rejected your claim outright, he was probably doomed either way.

  6. Well hmmm. Jeod says Louis doesn't have scatter so it can't have been her assuming two scum (I think that's a safe assumption until proven otherwise). FRAYDO tracked KY on n1 so I don't see how it could be him without using 12D chess. Tracking doesn't sound like an item action. Tho I am intrigued that he apparently has two night actions and was thinking that roleblocking me would be a better plan than tracking me for some reason.

    That leaves:

    Jeod: It could have been him, but he's been pretty helpful toward Louis. I'm having a hard time believing that he did it.

    ILTS: I... don't think so. Maybe if there is something incredibly strange going on. Doesn't seem likely.

    Orange: He is pretty adamant about being third party.

    Cat 5: Hard to see how he could use it both nights. On n2, maybe his masonry just extends. But on n1, he would have had to start it I think.

    Retal: Maybe there is some kind of extreme bus strategy going on here? The scatter does sound more like something his character could do... maybe.

    Me: My action failed, apparently due to deflection by scatter. If you want to believe, I was scum, why would I do this both nights and make my claim so early? I didn't even know what anyone did at that point.

  7. 5 minutes ago, Category 5 Hurricane said:

    Actually, and Jeod can verify this because I told it to him, I was initially suspect of Louis until you counterclaimed her. His verifications of Louis also helps.

    Which was something that would have been pretty dumb to do this early in the game if I were scum. Best case scenario, Louis gets lynched and then I get lynched the the next day. It doesn't make sense.

  8. 12 minutes ago, Category 5 Hurricane said:

    If I could vote, I would be going for Sunflower with not much doubt. She's claiming roleblocker but also claims to have been roleblocked twice, Scatter was used on me (perhaps because I was the only player that anyone publicly suggested anyone do anything to) and she has counterclaimed Louis's Doc role while also quietly being counterclaimed in the roleblock role by FRAYDO.

    There is too much here to ignore.

    Your tunnel vision is strong. I can kind of see that maybe at this point we all just need me to die, so I can be confirmed town once and for all and everyone can go from there to think about new angles based on the reveal. But I'm going to vote for you because usually you consider more angles than this if you're town.

    ##vote Cat 5

  9. 39 minutes ago, FRAYDO said:

    The fact she was "blocked" appears to me as a cover for the lack of the nightkill, although I also still believe no NK was attempted N2 either in the event of a track.

    Cat 5 is claiming that someone used "scatter" on him to block incoming actions. If true, that would explain my action failing and Louis's item pass failing. But I'm still having a hard time understanding why scum would use scatter on Cat 5 but not kill anyone.

  10. 6 minutes ago, Jeod said:

    Oh.

    By the way I’ve been wondering about a what-if scenario. What if orange was the n1 kill target instead of snipe? If KY had to do the kill then he couldn’t have used his scan. In that case he’d have passed an item to snipe.

    ILTS said that the wrath day ability he used was unlocked because someone tried to kill him. He could be lying, but it does kinda make sense.

×
×
  • Create New...