Jump to content

Jeod

Forum Game Masters
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    9,136

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    81

  • Donations

    5.00 USD 

 Content Type 

Everything posted by Jeod

  1. Jeod
    http://mafiawiki.notesmash.org/wiki/OMGUS
  2. Jeod
    Only it wasn't an instant assumption. Swap Misa's name with Nodlied and you'd be correct.
  3. Jeod
    I'll admit that when squared up with Rounders being chosen by RNG from the highest OC/RC%, the latter wins. There's still the matter of Misa being a suspect in either case, and her complete OMGUS to my vote.
  4. Jeod
    That's correct.
  5. Jeod
    Because Misa, Chop and I all visited you, yet only Chop and I are in a FGL. I hypothesized that for N0, the Rounders were chosen in the same manner.
  6. Jeod
    You forgot KY in there, by the way. The fact remains that I currently have more of a reason to lynch Misa than any of our other suspects.
  7. Jeod
    @CK: Precisely.
  8. Jeod
    I'd agree with that, except that we all have 15% OC as of today, so if Rounders weren't decided based on visiting N0, then it's been RNG'd. I considered that when I proposed lynching Nodlied, since there was no way to decide who would be the best lynch target, but then I began building the case for Misa's curious absence from a lab. As it so happen, she is also one of the players with a currently 15% OC.
  9. Jeod
    Furthermore, Misa has not made an attempt to refute my claims. For example, everyone who formed a FGL with someone last night 'met' their lab partner. Misa visited OP47 the same as myself and ChopBam. Did she receive anything in her PM to indicate our presence? I understand that she's new to mafia, but I expect new players to participate. She asked for evidence that was already presented, so she's smart enough to know that she should defend herself as well.
  10. Jeod
    Well, if she is indeed a Rounder, then she can do the same thing I asked Choppy to do if he was one: come out and say it, out the partner, and RNGUpa into another alignment. As sad as it is, two players are Rounders today and our goal is to find them. Such is mafia.
  11. Jeod
    Where am I asking others for guidance? I said very clearly at the start of the day that I would be hunting for a reason to vote a player instead of just doing a random D1 lynch. I have found that reason, I have articulated that reason, and it's being met with resistance despite the logic behind it. I'm simply requesting that, if players feel that it's incorrect, to present an alternative rather than submitting rebuttals that don't hold water and being in favor of an entirely random lynch.
  12. Jeod
    I agree with CK's assessment that there could only be two lab members in a FGL during N0->D1. However, that does not nullify the possibility that Misa could have become a Rounder with Chop. If I set all of that aside and pretend that I'm voting for Misa for the same reason I would have voted for Nodlied, then her reaction versus Nodlied's reaction is much more scum-vibed.
  13. Jeod
    CK, I'm not defensive. I'm annoyed at the small and weak attempts to poke holes in my reasoning simply because I have a reputation and because I appear to be "bullying" Misa. Show me some strong evidence that I shouldn't be voting for Misa over a random player today and I'll consider it. Until then, the only thing I'm getting is that a bunch of you are putting your heads in the sand just because Jeod's name is attached to the hypothesis.
  14. Jeod
    You're grasping at straws to try and explain why my hypothesis is incorrect by any means necessary, even to ridiculous ends, and I'm going to sit back and watch. It's funny how I'm the bad guy every time I attempt to play well. Meta is important for mafia yes, but if you rely on meta in every situation then you're going to be wrong.
  15. Jeod
    I'll reiterate: If my statements sound like I'm leading rather than making fair points and giving reason for my vote, then so be it.
  16. Jeod
    I'd hoped that my willingness to play as town would be more obvious.
  17. Jeod
    I've stated my goal from the beginning. I've made a best effort to lay out all the data. I've made my case for lynching Misa even though I initially suggested Nodlied. I have nothing more to add unless new data comes up.
  18. Jeod
    Sorry, but that doesn't make me want to give her a pass. Lurking and coasting is what it is, and I have solid hypotheses to base my case on.
  19. Jeod
    It does confirm the existence of a Rounder Doc, and given the way teams have been formed, it's logical to assume that Misa and ChopBam may have formed a Rounder Doc. The same could be said of Misa and myself. Objectively, ChopBam or myself could be a part of Rounder Doc while also being a part of FGL #4. I don't have an agenda here. I've said from the start of the day that I'm going to aim for direction in a first lynch. Lynching Misa makes more sense than lynching Nodlied, and there is a ton of information coming from her responses to my suggestions.
  20. Jeod
    Yet another response that only makes me more sure of my decision to push you. I've been leading the charge today, true, because I understand everything that's happening so far. I have nothing to hide, and in fact I don't think I've ever made any attempt to put "everyone else" in the spotlight. It is you who has gone mostly unnoticed for the majority of the day.
  21. Jeod
    Learn to read guys, and learn to scumread. Misa is our best bet over Nodlied.
  22. Jeod
    Let's back up and examine this for a moment. The CVC states that Nodlied is being voted twice and Misa only once, and so far only I have voiced an interest in lynching her. Yet the defensive and all-inclusive language suggests that she's genuinely afraid that she's been called out.
  23. Jeod
    For the last time: OC = 18% RNG > 18% = town RNG < 18% = scum RNG = 18% = unknown
  24. Jeod
    It's far more likely that his RNG roll was equal to his OC %, so alignment could not be determined.
  25. Jeod
    CVC: TheIrishMan voted no one OrangeP47 voted Nodlied FRAYDO voted no one Chaos_Knight voted no one Nodlied voted no one Jeod voted Misa Killing You voted no one Misa voted no one Mojoman voted no one Kamuixmod voted no one ChopBam voted Nodlied
×
×
  • Create New...