Player
Role
Alignment
Jeod
Ability copy
presumed Town (non-scum)
Killing You
Unstoppable day vig
Orange
Jailer
claimed Neutral
iLikeToSnipe
Vengeful doctor
Shade
Jack of All Trades
Nodlied
Hider
claimed Neutral
Cat5
Unknown
ChopBam
Tracker
Sunflower
Watcher
Vertigo
Lynch proof
So, we know Jeod got janitored. Since he was offed by scum and Orange confirmed his ability (which lead to Jeod successfully "testing" Orange) we still have a pretty good idea as to who Jeod was. A janitor ability is usually a one-time thing, it really doesn't make sense for scum to use it on Jeod. As soon as he got NK'd we knew that he was town, making his abilities and actions confirmed. So, why would scum even bother with a janitor kill? What if it was an ability that was a janitor kill AND an unstoppable kill?
I purposely announced that I was going to randomly select myself or Jeod to protect due to WIFOM, I flipped a coin and landed on me. Of course, scum can't know who I'll be protecting that night but Jeod is still a threat to being able to out them. If their janitor's kill is also unstoppable that would give them a reason to use it, thereby negating any protection roles that might be used on him. We also had Jeod's fake claim of being BP (which Orange went along with to his credit). My current theory is that a role with a combined janitor/unstoppable NK took Jeod out. I really can't think of any decent explanation as to why scum would choose to use a janitor on a role confirmed town beyond having unlimited usages.
With that in mind, let's refer to the claimed abilities listed above. We know Shade had a roleblock (I can back him up on that) and he used some sort of Liquidate ability on D2, we can reasonably assume that he doesn't have some kind of unstoppable janitor ability that turns people into mummies. Killing You was jailed by Orange last night, so he would have been unable to make the kill and is in the clear. We know that Vertigo is lynch proof, and never in my entire time playing mafia have I seen a scum member be given lynch proof. Lynch proof is just a town role, it's just far too powerful for scum to have; I doubt that he is scum.
That leaves us with me, Nodlied, Cat5, ChopBam, and Sunflower as the potential killers. I'm obviously going to exclude myself since I know I'm town. I doubt that we have more than one neutral in this game and due to Jeod's testing of Orange I think we can take Orange's word that he's neutral. So my number one suspect is Nodlied. Which conveniently lines up with him being jailed N1 and there being no NK N1. Typically if somebody tries to kill a bulletproof role with an NK the target will be alerted to the failed attempt. Since nobody has come forward with claims of a failed attempt N1 then one of two possibilities happened. The scum team chose not to perform a kill (which is usually a bad idea) or the person carrying it out was blocked somehow.
The only two players to claim to have been blocked on N1 were myself and Nodlied. So the lynch today should be between myself or Nodlied. Again, I know I'm town so...
Before we do anything else, I'd like feedback from the other players. I was out of it Saturday and Sunday and missed quite a bit. There's definitely facts and evidence I've missed and I'm trying to look back through it all. So I'd appreciate the feedback on this logic as well as what I'm about to propose.
I propose that KillingYou shoots Nodlied. Nodlied has claimed a neutral hider. He is not town and his top priority is to survive at all costs. He can and will betray us to the scum team if he is telling the truth. Should Nodlied flip as scum, then we probably bagged Jeod's killer (and it will indirectly confirm me).
If Nodlied does flip neutral then I propose that we force all the non-confirmed players to vote for me today. If any refuse to vote for me we pick one to lynch. I will flip town and I will be able to take out one of them with my vengeful ability. I probably don't have much longer to live with being a claimed doctor and I'll just muddy up the waters further.
Thoughts?