I didn't want to kill anon! I figured he was either the TP himself or just overly excited town. He kept saying/doing dumb things and Orange kept taking all that in the most uncharitable way possible.
I'm pressured to use my kill shot on someone today because of my claim. Knowing everything we know now I should have killed Orange, but it was less than a 50% chance to kill and he'd just use a fail to keep pushing an Anon/Retal pair. Better to eliminate that pairing myself.