Jeod

@ Louis Here is Shade's scumplay. You apparently did your action on TheIrishMan instead of me. Therefore, saying I was protected from the nightkill is moot. However, Shade does not want to establish that you do protect your targets when you put them in a cell. That kind of information in the public domain hurts scum. Read your PM carefully, and ask the host any clarifying questions you may have. It may be that he's right, but it's always best to hear it from the host.

You even tried manipulating Louis with the jailer vs roleblocker thing to your benefit.

Because I'm the only one who scumreads you at the moment and am the safe mislynch?

Not my fault my role should be tp but isn't.

That's essentially the definition of a jailer. The wording matches up with what happened to me as well. Yet you ended up holding TheIrishMan in a cell apparently.

A short summary/reminder that of the eight players, only four players have reported any form of actions with clarity: Jeod - Tried to pass his item to Shade and spent the night in a cell Louis - Tried to roleblock/jail Jeod and somehow ended up targeting TheIrishMan TheIrishMan - Got jailed by his own claim Category 5 - Witnessed or directed Louis targeting TheIrishMan

As great as that would be, it gives way to a few contradictions.

Category 5 claims you visited TheIrishMan, who claims he was jailed. Are you absolutely certain you are not a jailer?

Jailer is a protection role. I wouldn't want to make them known just as equally as scum wouldn't want to admit they were jailed.

To me the several above quotes laid out read as if Category 5 were directly insinuating the following: 1) That he believes Louis' claim as a jailer 2) That he does not believe there's a second jailer 3) That he knew Louis jailed TheIrishMan (and believes I was not jailed) because he redirected Louis from me to TheIrishMan via bus.

Could have, but then why would you feel the need to say you don't believe I was also jailed? The natural and logical conclusion is a bus driver.

The really sad thing about Shade is that whenever he's wrong he waves it off as the other player's fault for "not playing well". He can never accept blame.

Here, try it for yourself. It's quite cool.

It’s called putting the pieces together and logically filling in the blanks.

I don’t follow.

Louis said she targeted me and jailed Irish. That doesn’t affect who I target.

Never mind it was me and Irish. So in the end I still ended up visiting shade.

@ Category 5 Hurricane Who we’re your bus targets again?

I sat in a cell overnight. Whether it means jailed or blocked via visiting my target is the unknown. If it’s the former then something funky is going on with the bus driver claim. If it’s the latter then shade isn’t vanilla.

That said, now that my point of view is fully on the table: ##vote Shade939

I'd argue scum wouldn't have known kills could fail. Shade was the one who was first sniffing for third party/neutral, almost everyone else was led to believe this was a simple basics setup with a pinch of Dune flavor. If anything I would expect scum to know about potential existence of third party via scumdoc before what kind of town roles they're up against.

It's all about trains of thought just before and during the night phase.

Shade is still my #1 scum suspect. Everything in my perspective of events leads to him over the other vanilla claims.

Right here.