Jump to content

OrangeP47

Forum Game Masters
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    11,352

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    23

  • Donations

    0.00 USD 

 Content Type 

Posts posted by OrangeP47

  8. [Game Over: Town Victory] Star Trek: Away Team

    in Forum Games

    Posted

    Just now, Mojoman said:

    And the logic for scum not wanting to be sent doesn't really work, since that's their win condition. It's better for them to be on the away team and create discord, rather than trying to go together. So actually, I'd like to change my nomination to the same as the Cat_5's, since there's no possible way it would be good for a scum team to both NOT be on the away team.

    As it stands, we're sidelining you anyway without you being fingered for a sabotage.

    0

  9. [Game Over: Town Victory] Star Trek: Away Team

    in Forum Games

    Posted

    1 minute ago, Category 5 Hurricane said:

    And I still think that reasoning is a scum reasoning. There is no reason for a town player to want to avoid being sent. There is no risk to looking suspicious as you have no risk of being removed. The risk for town is sending a scum player to the away team. Now, a scum player may consider being sent a risk as once they sabotage a mission the target will be on their backs for the rest of the game.

    I mean, we've been ragging on Shade, but with the variable away team size, I'm pretty sure this game is set up where everybody is gonna have to do something at some point. And I mean that in a very certain way, in that while not everyone may go on an away team perhaps, everyone is gonna at least have to *try* to get on the away team to fulfil their win con.  You can't sit this out.

    0

  10. [Game Over: Town Victory] Star Trek: Away Team

    in Forum Games

    Posted

    Just now, Category 5 Hurricane said:

    Oh, absolutely, you being targeted like that should make you basically clear. On the flipside, if you targeted yourself...also why you and not TownBote? And you have more or less confirmed you have an action. So all of it is possible. Still, I'm leaning pretty heavily towards Louis being scum, and Orange may have just sold me he's town. Mojoman's reluctance to be sent with Louis also stands out.

    I mean, it's not like I was 100% on Louis-Mojo at daystart, but it really does feel like I took a stab at a random team, hit the mark, and they flipped out.

    0

  11. [Game Over: Town Victory] Star Trek: Away Team

    in Forum Games

    Posted

    2 minutes ago, Category 5 Hurricane said:

    I was thinking either there we no night actions at all, or that only scum would have them. Jeod talking about having one was actually making me question him.

    To be fair while Jeod having one is *slightly* sus, I don't feel the need to bin him just yet.  I feel pretty confident with you and me and townbot, and then we can give him another crack at it N3 and town is still ahead.

    0

  20. [Game Over: Town Victory] Star Trek: Away Team

    in Forum Games

    Posted

    1 minute ago, Jeod said:

    I'd think the opposite. I would expect a sabotage because if there isn't one they're just giving us one more win (2/3). Even if they're both scum, it isn't in their best interest to let it slide because we'll likely be rotating players again the following mission regardless of what happens.

    I mean it'd be a bad spot to be in either way, so ideally step one would be to try to avoid it if they can, which *certain* people seem to have tried to do with mucho gusto as soon as I proposed it.

    0

  22. [Game Over: Town Victory] Star Trek: Away Team

    in Forum Games

    Posted

    Just now, Jeod said:

    I'm actually not super hyped for that. I feel like they're catering to nostalgia goggles so I'll wait for some gameplay vids and crowd reviews before buying. Unlike Diamond/Pearl, which is a classic to me.

    I mean, if Snap is longer than like 6-8 hours I'll be happy.  It just needs to be long enough to be worthwhile.  And yeah, hyped for the Gen 4 games even though I dislike Sinnoh, but those are further away.  All the hate seems to be "ewww artstyle" and not much substance so I haven't paid attention to it.  The actual mechanics seem on par with any pokemon games from what's been exhibitied.

    0

  23. [Game Over: Town Victory] Star Trek: Away Team

    in Forum Games

    Posted

    Just now, Jeod said:

    Well, you do have an untrustworthy reputation, kinda like how Cat5 has a tendency to be townread. It's just that people tend to scumread you when they're on the fence and need to lean a certain way. That's why I jumped at the chance to go on the first mission. I also didn't know whether we would still be allowed to use actions or if we'd be blocked from them when on missions. I wanted to find out.

    Does anyone have a problem with the content of my idea that if both scum are on the away mission they'd be hesitant to sabotage because they'd throw both themselves and their teammate under the bus, hence the possible reason for this reaction?  Arguments should be based off content not character.

    0
×
×
  • Create New...