Shade939
-
Posts
8,419 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
17 -
Donations
0.00 USD
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Documentation
Bug Tracker
Downloads
Posts posted by Shade939
-
-
Also, if Jeod was jailed, he likely couldn't have passed an item could he?
0 -
1 minute ago, Category 5 Hurricane said:
As established by other roles, the timing of the use of the abilities/items matters. Louis apparently doesn't live if she doesn't use her shield N2. TheIrishman maybe missed his opportunity to use his at the correct time. If Jeod was actually jailed, he failed to use it when he could have. Scum not knowing whether or not my ability will be used is an advantage I'm not giving up.
Do you expect the rest of Town to trust you while hiding your role from them at this stage of the game?
0 -
Just now, Category 5 Hurricane said:
Mr. Alternate Universe Man, I know I gave you that name, but just because that is who you are now, doesn't mean I have to play by the rules of the alternate realities that you create for yourself.
No, this is the alternate reality you're creating for yourself.
Let's continue with it, and see if it matches up with our expectations of what happened in the game.
0 -
If your story is true, then let's treat it and such and continue from there shall we?
Jeod started the game with an item that would counteract your role ability.
0 -
I must obviously know your ability already based off of the item I have since it would be made solely to counteract your role.
In fact, I would have known about it from the start of the game.
0 -
Just now, Category 5 Hurricane said:
How should I know? I do not know the lore. However, Jeod might have already told us, given his story about a "defensive jailer"
Shouldn't you list your own role already? Seeing as I must obviously be scum and have already been caught? Shouldn't that help build your case?
0 -
Just now, Category 5 Hurricane said:
I'll even point out that three happens to be the number of town power roles there are, if Louis and TheIrishman are the other two. Did you not say that each item is geared to counter a power role? I'm not sure I buy that this is a coincidence.
So, what item would you theorize could be used to counter your ability?
0 -
1 minute ago, Category 5 Hurricane said:
He also said he tried to pass one of them to you as part of his dance. Is that where it is, Shade?
I think I would be far more likely to remember that it was missing from his inventory if I was actually holding onto it, and has to actually plan on how to use it wouldn't I?
0 -
3 minutes ago, Category 5 Hurricane said:
Why don't you explain why you initially said Jeod had three items?
Didn't correctly remember how many items he had based off the death message, and I thought it had listed three items. There are some downsides to being lazy about quoting previous post for reference.
0 -
Just now, Category 5 Hurricane said:
A traditionally anti town busing role?
0 -
1 minute ago, Category 5 Hurricane said:
Seeing that a vanilla scum might exist, given Jeod's
threetwo items, that would seem to hamper the usefulness of an ability cop for town. Granted, seeing that my ability, if used correctly, is also a way to verify people as town, could be an ok pairing of weak abilities.What ability is that again?
0 -
6 minutes ago, Retaliation said:
What about if I...
Spoiler
0 -
So, can I vote Category 5 Hurricane again then?
0 -
1 minute ago, TheIrishman said:
It says I check their roster for any skills, if any. So probably NK too
NK wouldn't be listed on their roster I'd assume, and as I'd suspect, Jeod's partner would have an ability to actually support Jeod as he made the NK and have an ability then.
0 -
I'm confident in claiming that the Drone would be a way to bypass a roleblock.
So perhaps, the technology scrambler would have worked against any item another player was using then, so it could be used against Louis or Irish then?
0 -
My main wonder would be the item you had and the item Jeod had, since I would think they'd counter each other, despite being one shot passive for both of you?
0 -
Just now, TheIrishman said:
Oh and full claim, I'm an ability cop which works pretty well as a standard cop in a game with 3 to 4 vanilla town. I could easily see how this could be used against me tho as it's a popular scum role but I'm the only investigative role, aside from potentally Cat5.
Except for Jeod, who only had items to rely on so he wouldn't show up as having an ability.
0 -
2 minutes ago, TheIrishman said:
Okay, that's not what I expected. I had to use them on the same person because the item wouldn't let me target anyone with it, just to activate it as I visited. Otherwise I would've picked you and Retal. Passing it to a vanilla player would've made it useless. I was pretty confident that we aren't able to target players with items and that's why Shade was saying vanilla town can't have items. I expected it to say so in all vanilla PM's with Shade's certainty of the statement and nobody debating it and since there's no point in them having an item like mine.
Agh, ok, you're referencing when I fist told everyone that we had vanilla roles in game with no items or abilities, so if they could do anything at all, that basically made them a power role in this setup, which meant they should play around that fact accordingly.
0 -
Also, do you actually mean can't have items, or didn't have items? I'm assuming you meant the later, but the former is probably accurate also, would you expect Louis to pass her BP to someone else?
0 -
Just now, TheIrishman said:
Before this, Shade. How are you certain vanilla town can't have items?
Because I didn't have any items, and I'm a vanilla town role. Therefore I should know what other vanilla town roles have to work with in game.
I'm assuming that the GM didn't make me the only role in game without any items or abilities after all.
0 -
Don't take my comment seriously by the way, consider it a reference to command and conquer drones and mines.
0 -
3 minutes ago, Retaliation said:
Shade is confused. Hunter seekers are from rebarn.
Maybe Category 5 has a limpet drone then?
0 -
On 4/25/2022 at 11:10 AM, Shade939 said:
And I'll make a quick reference to assassin drones about the size of a bee being a thing, and possibly cloning technology.
3 minutes ago, FRAYDO said:I have re-read through the thread and checked Ctrl+F "hunter" on each page. You have never told anyone earlier here about Hunter Seeker Drones.
0 -
19 minutes ago, Retaliation said:
What if Jeod was blocked because he tried to pass an item to Irish? Has this been considered?
I believe the answer lies in what ability Category 5 used on Irish.
That would shatter that entire mystery, yet he's refused to even share or hint at what that ability is, and all of our information about it has come from second handed sources, one of which was Scum.
0
[GAME OVER- ATREIDES VICTORY] Battle for Dune Mafia 1
in Forum Games
Posted
Not at all, if I remember correctly, he wanted to steal an item from me based off of my day one joke post, by trading a spice container with me as his made up smuggler role claim.
Also, does this put us at at 50/50 then Category 5?