Wait wait wait... Okay if scatter is an item and that whoever is scum then, right? Here is my break down
I definitely know I'm town from how many consistency I've had from my reports.
Jeod - I know he's not scum because I stole from him N1 and the only thing I received is Gummies which is worthless unless eaten and gives Jeod knowledge. And from what I've read he doesn't have anything significant.
FRAYDO - he isn't scum, I stole from him N2 and N3 and he still didn't have any items.
iLTS - you guys assumed that I visited him but I only passed the gummies to him and I didn't steal anything from him. It I don't think he's scum because he was attacked N1 which clearly rules him out.
Cat5 - I don't believe he's scum either, he just sounds a little confused to me and I think he's telling the truth about the report. But let's say in this scenario he is scum why would he willingly give us info on the item Scatter. He could have left us still confused about what happened to Sunflower (sorry).
Which leads me to
Retal - he's the one that confuses me the most. He's shifty to me, he's not really telling us anything but saying he'll kill us haha