Okay, I have four suspects that could have attempted this night kill (super helpful...) but I'm going to try and narrow them down.
Shade939:
He was super aggressive when I first asked for any info on visitors. Shade's meta is to be a bulldog, but this still seems like some misplaced aggression. He then claims he received a cursed item that he has to get rid of. Orange is correct that Shade hasn't made gambits like that in the past, but it could be something his scummate would have suggested. Shade doesn't have any proof he received this item, and he also claims that it was likely a third party. Third party wouldn't know who scum is, they're just as likely to pass it to scum as to town. So we just have a bunch of aggression and unprovable claims.
Killing_You:
He's been kind of below the radar and just coasting. I don't think it was suspicious of him to ask about Shade's cursed item. That's what any good town member should do when a suspect makes a claim. That said, it's awfully convenient that his action had a small chance of succeeding and FRAYDO had no notification.
TheIrishman:
Almost no content today. I've got a town read on him from yesterday, but I'd still like to hear his thoughts.
Nodlied:
All we know is that he gave an item to Shade at the start of the game. Besides that he's also not said much regarding who could be responsible. Null read on him as well.
The evidence seems stacked against Shade, but I'd like to hear from @Killing_You, @TheIrishman, and @Nodlied on who they think out of the four is responsible. It's pretty bad that we have almost nothing to go off of besides Shade.
If anybody else wants to weigh in (i.e. you disagree on who doesn't have an alibi) then please do so. We need to nail scum.
If I had to pick somebody right now I'd pick Shade. But I'd still like to hear from the others. I will be placing my vote tomorrow before hammer.