I mean, you could just pay attention in the thread, I rue wasting my second night post on this, but I'll lay out all the reasons.
1) I'm vehemently against no lynch (in non CYOR games)
2) Recall early on (like the first *real life* day of the game) when I called Shade out for several meta inconsistencies. He wasn't sitting right with me the entire phase, even if I was joking it up about it. It was half joking/half serious.
3) His shot wasn't the best. Now you may say, but Orange, he shot the guy you were casing/voting. Yeah, he did. But look at how he handled it. Look at the WAY he did it. I was gonna make a separate point for it, but really it goes here, think about this in conjuncture with the fact that he pretty quickly pivoted to no lynch after his shot failed instead of voting Anon. Yeah, we now know Shade was town, but he wasn't acting town.
2 and 3 means Shade is a valid target in my book, 1 means if the trains are no lynch and someone else, I'm going to try to steer it away from no lynch, assuming the other train is not someone I'm feeling is town, which again, points 2 and 3. This is entirely consistent with everything I do.