OrangeP47

Sometimes mafia really is that easy

lol

?

Nah this is a continuation of yesterday's "It's not Cat 5"

In that you're acting like you're the only one who's allowed to theorize in a 5 person game.

Then aren't you kind of being a hypocrit?

This game is math heavy Jeod, accept it. Also use buzz words correctly.

I mean low key Mojo's made some good points and sometimes he doesn't play optimally so it's possible for it to be Louis/Jeod but I think I'm gonna bet on it being Louis/Mojo first and then if we're wrong adjust later.

I mean, if we're actually gonna have to work at it, I'd still say Jeod is more sus than Cat 5, which was really my logic there. While you did have a good point, my actual thinking hasn't changed and if something goes wrong I'm still gonna probably look to Jeod before Cat 5, but that's now contingent on the fact that there was no sabotage last night. If there had been sabotage last night, then yes, that'd fingered Cat 5 pretty heavily.

Lol no I live for antagonizing Cat 5 (See Death Note Mafia, where you specifically told me not to do it but I did it anyway and look what happened)

pretty much describes how I'm just sitting here like "Oh really?"

Like seriously, we are the one who knocks. Doing anything other than taking Jeod is scum asking us to put the gun down.

Everything is predestined it doesn't matter what we do, our choices are to win now or win later.

Mojo, the math works out so it doesn't matter if we do it now or later, so I'd rather take Jeod now on the off chance we're just right and win now, the game will be shorter instead of faffing around for no reason.

I mean, it's the only way the strategy would have worked. Weather you would do it or not is irrelevant.

No, that wouldn't be throwing them under the bus. But for scum to win, scum have to be on the away team. Scum can't win by voting for town to go on missions all game long.

If Jeod was playing the long con, he'd still have tried to get his partner on the away team yesterday, and I don't see evidence of that.

This is the thing too, the only universe where I accept Jeod being scum is where he pulled this play on accident. Doesn't mean it's not possible, but just saying, if he did this on purpose, it wasn't a smart play, so I'm inclined to believe he wasn't trying it.

I mean, I've considered it, but I'm not gonna worry about it too much unless it actually happens. As of right now it'd be dumb to not do what we're doing. Going with the unproven team because the proven team isn't 100% proven is a bad move when the proven team has still gotten us 2/3 of the way to victory without taking any hits.

Imagine if a town was in quarantine for this mission.

I mean technically today, if there's two scum, we're taking EVERYBODY who isn't scum, so if we weren't just so sure we'd kinda get dinged today for sure.

Then this really would be Secret Hitler.

Just had a thought, imagine if Shade made it so there's only 1 scum, or the scum can't talk to each other or something. What a world.

Honestly, I'm not 100% you aren't pulling some kind of long con, but if you are it's not a great play so I'm not too worried. I think we really did just make it this simple. I mean, whatever happens next night, scum messed up last night, which I think puts the clear more heavily on Cat 5 and me. I can't see scum *willingly* and *knowingly* letting it get this close to town victory. In your case, if you're theoretically scum (which to be clear, I'm not accusing you of being, I'm just spitballing here), I could reasonably see a world where this all happened because you didn't have the full info of how the future would go down as opposed to just playing bad.

I'd have so many more jokes if any of you had watched Lower Decks and knew the story of Peanut Hamper.