He wasn't the scum we nailed D1. We actually nailed someone unrelated because of a bizzare typo incident that's hard to explain. Basically the setup is 3 mafia, 10 vanilla town, and 2 jack of all trades. One JOAT claimed, one vanilla fake claimed (we don't know it's fake), one scum member was recapping what happened and typoed the fake claimer as an unrelated person. Everyone is like "Eh?" Unrelated person freaks out, reveals they are the second JOAT for real. Really, this isn't a reason to suspect that scum member, because how could they have possibly known this? Still, everyone is so agro we basically consensus vote them out because it's D1 and there's not much else to do, and surprise surprise, we eliminate a scum D1.