Shade939

Here's the quick summary.

##Vote Shade939 Honestly, it's still probably too overly complicated to proceed without getting myself cleared first.

To be fair, I don't think we have any protective roles in games, so it should end tomorrow regardless of who scum is.

I wonder if Scum had any obvious ability that would let them get around that.

##Unvote Shade939 Actually, why are you so insistent that doctor didn't' self target Orange?

Why is that obvious?

Which still hasn't been explained by the way.

For an early hammer when I was asking about Category 5's death still?

That's very specifically one of the problems I'm running into also, about the only way that anyone is proving they're a Town member in this game is just a GM message for using an ability or having targeted Scum previously. Since I don't' have any night actions like that, it's basically unavoidable that I'd be lynched barring you actually considering Scum have an action that makes them sound like Town.

And the GM sent a message to the player when you visit them...

I think it's a sign of if we're going to vote me up and force you to make the harder choice tomorrow, can we go ahead and hurry up then.

##Vote Shade939

Yeah, and that still doesn't change the fact that the game isn't going to end with my death.

No, you have to agree it makes perfect sense you wouldn't lynch the Cop in a game. Therefore if that Cop was a member of the Mafia, it would still make sense that you wouldn't try to lynch them.

It's the perfect ability to give a Mafia member since it means they probably wouldn't be lynched for the entire game then.

Why would you lynch someone with a confirmed Cop ability?

Pretty certain that would be a good reason to put something like a Mafia Cop in game then.

Then why put a Doctor and Tracker in game with only eight players?

We already have a Doc in game, would we really need a Tracker and a Cop then?

Some guy called the Mandarin gave them to me if I remember the comic version of the character correctly.

1. No, my character is very specifically trying to help improve the city. 2. Sunflower, honestly I'm not certain I buy her claim of being a cop, she has an ability which makes her appear to be one, but it's just as likely that she's only claiming that role after hearing how Irish described the GM message he received for being PM'd by KY. 3. No, I don't think the intention would have been to get him lynched, especially since that would have given Scum the numbers advantage to end the game sooner. 4. Nope, never been to Romania. 5. Actually, they're a piece of alien technology that let's me shoot energy blast as people. 6. Nine and Foggy Nelson.

Go ahead. Although, in all fairness it would probably make more sense for Irish to go first since everyone seems to be assuming I'm the most likely Scum candidate.

So, it would make more sense for Scum's abilities to have to force them to be used in combination in order to win the game, rather than accounting for one of them being killed off if by nothing more than RNG at game start?

You consider it illogical that rather than preventing Jeod from using his night action from now on, that he wouldn't simply be allowed to perform his action and the NK instead if he had been the last surviving Mafia member?

Or perhaps Mafia can only perform two actions after their teammate was killed...