Jeod

Why not put up a signup thread and be elastic with the type of game that will be hosted depending on signups? You could even allow conditional signups if you're not sure e.g. "I'll play if we end up playing X or Y".

It's obvious that with 12 people voting and more than 12 total poll votes that some people didn't realize they could select multiple options. I'm among those. Considering that data and allowing for a margin of error, I'd wager that Star Wars, TS Reborn, and CYOR are your three contenders.

I think you're being too methodical about it. There appears to already be a majority indication that Star Wars and CYOR flavors would be the most desired, while most if not all players would join either one if hosted.

I couldn't vote on the second poll. I have no preference in regards to TS: Reborn or CYOR. I would play either one.

Hey Jarmo! Ditto to FRAYDO's statement. I'm curious, Sole Survivor was a failed attempt to put aspects of a FPS into an RTS. I don't think it had a lot of interest, and the project was abandoned in favor of Renegade. Could be wrong, but from my understanding, what is your drive for resurrecting this mechanic? Will you be changing the rules to make it more fun and less of a "he who fires first wins" thing?

Do a mashup.

Well, CYOR seemed to capture the most interest. However, I haven't been able to play in any besides the one Irish hosted.

If you'll be busy and you have an APB setup in mind, go for it now. I'm completely fine with pushing CYOR III back to January.

This was a well-organized game, Orange! I wish I'd done better--I definitely helped scum by not pushing on the "Retaliation was made insane for one night" thing, as paranoid as that is. It did make sense, which is why I even brought it up. As I said in the dead doc, I also had a feeling that I would be the nightkill due to clues I saw in TheIrishMan's posts. However, I didn't mention it because I'd already met my two post limit. On LYLO, I'd have ensured town's loss by gaining a vote penalty over it. I did not see Cat5 being a bodyguard at all, even after his death. Weird. As for CYOR III, I'll post a sign-up thread in an hour or two. The actual start date of the game might change though if @VERTi60 has a game in mind. I've been informed that he's been informed that this game is over.

As bastard as it is, I still believe there’s a strong possibility that Retaliation had his sanity altered. If I had to choose one person with the ability I’d name Irish, who we still know almost nothing about. Besides, his abilities are “blocked” remember? Or did you just slip, dear Kruschev?

Typical Mojoman being awful town with zero effort. Retaliation, about that report...

Yeah, Chopbam hammered.

I'm ok with an early hammer at this point. Mojoman's had several hours now to defend himself and come clean about his role and reasons for claiming Canadian as a Cuban. It's not MYLO, and we'll have 5 players tomorrow unless a NK is prevented. If Retaliation turns out to be scum, then he's partnered with Nodlied who backed Retaliation's report. I can't see there being more than two scum in this game.

I missed the part where he claimed to have a report. It was probably the middle of the night when I read those bits.

Mojoman and Retaliation could be saying more though. A masonry was made, and so far all we know is that Mojoman is Castro and that he returned a scum report. Both claims are only by Retaliation; Mojoman has neither confirmed nor denied them.

While I'm for lynching Mojoman today, something about this feels way off. It's too simple and too easy. ##vote Mojoman

According to my wiki entry, Taylor was essentially “Praise Kennedy” during the Cold War.

Maxwell D. Taylor at your service.

I’m not Len Billings.

My only qualm with the rush to pounce on mojo is the possibility that you were hit with something that swaps your report. We also haven’t heard from everyone yet.

Well, mojo? Time to spill the beans.

A scum masonry ability would be out of left field...sounds like the kind of thing OP47 would do. Besides, if it’s wrong, it’s your neck on the line. Plenty of time for debating what direction we take though.

It’s a possibility. Not confirmed.

Retaliation do you have an indication you may have been messed with overnight? Perhaps an ability that could swap your report for the target?

I played a gambit that paid off. I watched KY. Nobody visited him, and you’re not dead.