OrangeP47

Guess you might be the last man standing then, regardless of me being town :\ ##Vote Louis

I mean this seems memey as hell, but like, that "but wait, Louis didn't pass me an item", seriously, what the hell was that?!

Because it's not me, and you're both voting me, so if this it, it's game over, but if it's actually Cat 5, town can still win if we vote him now and he doesn't scramble. ##Vote Cat 5

Louis, this means we can vote him and he can't scramble if he's away!

Are you really the scum and just stringing both of us along here?

Did FRAYDO pass you the item?

AND NOBODY IN THE DEAD DOC SAY "BECAUSE SHE IS A NINJA" OR WHATEVER NARUTO IS

Like who is there to fool aside from you? You could make the argument now that I have the radar and someone else could have taken it that theoretically anyone could have gotten the radar, but still....

Oh yeah, this. Also again, why would she have a ninja modifer?

But I'll admit that's just tinfoil. The only one who knows why is Louis, I'll agree it doesn't make sense.

If she's scum, she'd believe you that you have no night actions and thus would go no where, but she wouldn't know where I'd go, and thus couldn't claim to track me or else could get caught in a lie. Her goal would have been to push it onto me, but knowing that I'd obviously know it wasn't me, my defense would be much more vigourous.

I mean, if you're asking how scum me would play a situation where I'm trying to get Louis mislynched, the answer is identical. I mean, not realistically, but theoretically. I aim to only have one meta. I don't have a town game or a scum game, just a game, so the tools I use as either alignment are identical. Just sometimes I'm pushing the truth and sometimes I'm pushing a fiction. It's unfortunate that that means others can't tell which is which, but it's why I'm good when I'm scum, and that's my goal across all games. If it causes me to lose as town now, whelp, gg.

I was expecting her to track you to the kill.

Is this rhetorical?

The instant people visit me I hand out items. This has been confirmed. If I had such an item there's no way I'd had been able to hold onto it.

If you want a honest answer, I guess Louis could have the ability. She's unknown enough to have it. I've been confirmed enough with my actions for you to know I didn't do it.

And I've said this previously.

TBH I just ignored that whole post because I didn't want to be influenced by a possible scum gambit.

I suppose so, but I didn't see it that way, probably in part because I'm used to making the argument against Shade, and specifically Shade's fishing expeditions (and said as such in a few posts) which also colored my response. I tend to default, in these role heavy, closed setup games, that giving out your role too early is bad as town, so I saw what ILTS did as a bad move for town. Granted, I considered that he might just not care, in which case, okay, but I latched onto Mojo possibly sharing my concerns, and it's nice to be validated every once in a while

And while I had the alignments wrong, I stand by my logic at the time.

Because he made a good point, and scum can make good points (I do so as scum quite often, I imagine). I guess in the retrospective we already did on it, it was kinda clear I was projecting some of my own logic onto it. See this comment for a refresher:

I mean, you could always prompt us with questions But now is actually a bad window as I have the heating and AC people about to show up in 15 minutes to give an estimate on fixing the AC before the summer.

Thank you.

I now have over 9000 posts.