Yeah, the townclaim rubbed me the wrong way too. Though Chopbam tends to do that to me regardless it seems.
That said, I don't trust Cat 5, here's why.
1) His avatar is some kind of detective *guy*
2) That means he's not an anime girl
3) That means he's up to something./
4) That means I don't trust him.
That said, day 1 nominate probably doesn't matter too too much, unless there's an item already in there, and unless whoever we lynch has good items, etc. I'd much prefer to be the day 2 nomination, if it were me.