Honestly, Irish has the weakest Mafia claim unsurprisingly, but even then he has the profile picture to back up his claim from the last game when he was a Doc, and if anything his claim really makes too much sense so I'm wondering if things are really that convenient, but they probably are. And even if he's actually town I'm confident that you and Category 5 are Mafia so at worst I'm looking at a 50% chance to lynch a Town member by going after Orange without considering Jeod's actions. Category 5 is putting in too much effort this game if he was Scum, plus the day one no lynch was definitely not in his favor if he was Town.
Once you consider the extent to which Jeod is defending Orange and the two are working together with their post, and Orange hasn't once brought up the possibility that Jeod is scum, plus some of the really ridiculous claims Jeod has been reaching for, I'm perfectly happy with betting on lynching Orange today.