Killing_You

If you think you can run it quickly. I'm posting an interest thread right now, but that'll stay open for a while, and then the sign-ups for the actual game will occur, and then balancing and such. I'd be up for it.

I just now realized your line about being the "Hero of this story" was a subtle hint as to your alignment....

I know from Death Note what a devious bastard you are, so I'm not surprised You played a good game, you deserve the win, and I look forward to the next mafia with you.

First of all, way to use my trust like that, Orange. (Although I'd like to see how effective of a town team we make in the future). It definitely changes the dynamic of the mason, though. I would not be surprised if future masons got the spotlight because of this game. I'm also not sure how to feel about Mr. Frankenstein. Overall, though, this was a fun game. It'll probably be early April before the game is ready, since I'll have to do an interest for which flavor and then sign-ups for the game itself. Also, Jeod, I think a better solution would be to have people submit multiple requests and balance accordingly. Half the fun of CYOR is seeing what crazy stuff people come up with.

I'll post my thoughts momentarily, but for now, is someone else supposed to go next, or can I go ahead and make an interest thread?

Last night, while just derping around on ECW, @Fogbot3 and I wondered if we could take on the Defiant-class battlecruiser guarding Hell Island using two Dreadnaughts, the most powerful player controlled ship in the game. The result? Well, watch the video Featuring additional commentary by @Ice.

We did, until you encouraged that very plan yourself. Plus, we may need that for the abomination. Besides, we have an hour left until hammer, and we aren't 100% certain who we'd lynch in your place.

I was about to say... eks dee.

Sweet. Okay, let's run the numbers. First, let's assume everyone's claims are true. After all, out of those 3 hostile actions, only 1 wasn't confirmed by the opening day post. 1. Kill- TheIrishman 2. Gather Corpse- FRAYDO 3. Steal Item- OrangeP47 Now let's run them again, but this time, let's assume Shade's right and now I'm part of Orange's "cult." This would technically count me as a hostile. 1. Mesmetron- TheIrishman- FAIL (Death) 2. Stalk- Retaliation 3. Gather Corpse- FRAYDO Seems like both scenarios match up pretty evenly, eh? Well, here's the problem. In the former scenario (the one I believe to be true), this assumes Irish is a lone cult member, and we have a scum team of 2. 6 town, 1 Neutral, 1 TP Cult, and 2 scum at game start. Now, in the latter scenario, the only way this could be possible is if Orange and Shade were the only hostiles at game start. Basically, we would then have 7 town members, 1 Neutral, and 2 (separate!) TP cults at game start. This is an outlandish game setup. I think this speaks for itself.

Impossible. I tracked you, which you confirmed. Also, he masoned with me, and confirmed he could only use it every other night, and saved it for last night (when it got stolen). Had he used his item, I would've been roleblocked.

Retaliation, you said three hostiles acted last night, correct?

You know, I think we're done for the day. The case is effectively closed on shade, and the sooner we can stop his drivel from distracting us, the better. ##vote hammer

You're flip flopping more than a sock in the dryer. First you suggest that I'm scum with a partner that stole Orange's item, then you push the idea that Orange is a cult leader after the slightest bit of off-hand concern from Retaliation? Honestly, if we want to get technical, you'd be the "cult leader." HISSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSsssssssssssssssssss

You can't be serious.

I didn't steal it, and even if I wanted to (or could), I was busy with Retaliation. Try again, scrub.

I guess that makes me Snakemeat (instead of Dogmeat)

Good question. I originally wanted to be invisible to my target, but it was changed for some reason. It makes me wonder if there's a scum tracker that we're unaware of.

Orange, pls no be mad at me for this. He masoned with me N1. I'm out of contact now, and he can only do so every other night.

My night 1 target was Shade. And, as he said, he didn't do anything because he was roleblocked. And since this is sure to raise questions, I should also mention that my passive renders me invisible to trackers and watchers.

If that's the case, I'll definitely be thrown for a loop. We might have to consider the possibility that scum have powerful enough day actions to warrant the two dayblockers.

What's your reasoning?

There's also that five player cop game where you had no trouble steamrolling town because NoSpoons decided to lie for some reason. Unfortunately, said game got nuked by the forum upgrade that happened shortly after it was over. And who would that be?

I'm not the first one to do such a thing, and I won't be the last. It's to the point where claiming yourself town on such a chart is something I'd consider innocuous.

Well, let me run down the list of players myself. Category 5 Hurricane- Honestly not sure what to make here. For a little bit there, he was a bit out of character, but not in the way I'd expect a scum Cat5 to behave. Null read for now. ChopBam- Pretty sure he's town. I highly doubt he's anything else, or else I might call shenanigans on that lynch. Killing You- Town snek is town. Nodlied- Been pretty cagey about his role, and the only one without a night report from last night. Admittedly, I don't have much on him, but he's my strongest scum read so far. OrangeP47- Been playing pretty decently so far. I've got good reason to believe he's town. Retaliation- Roleblocked on the night with no nightkill. That being said, I have no other reasons to really suspect him. In fact, he told the truth about what he did last night, so I'm leaning towards town. I'm not ruling out the possibility of him being scum, however, but I don't have enough to make a case on him. Shade939- Claims hostile third party. Spouting a lot of stuff to try and prolong his life. Pretty sure the threat will be over when he dies, but we'll have to keep an eye out. Sunflower- Roleblocked Retaliation on the night with no nightkill. It's possible this was done deliberately to implicate Retal. Also has a dayshot, which Shade wants used on himself, presumably as part of his plan. Null read, leaning towards scum. Oh I think he's lying through his teeth to try and scare us. He might also be scum trying to distract us with nonsense while scum operate unhindered (A similar gambit happened in APB Mafia III, where Jeod had town running in circles trying to shut down a Chrono Vortex while he mopped up town).

Problem is, he requested it. I don't think we should follow through on this plan. Which means our best course of action is discuss who else we suspect to be scum while Shade waits patiently for the noose.