iLikeToSnipe

If I were to pick just one of the two, I'm leaning towards Mojoman for scum.

Sorry if that wasn't clear, didn't mean that you are scum. Meant that it's a scum tell for other players if we forget that they're playing. i.e. trying to fly under the radar

That's exactly why I'm suspicious. If you forget somebody is playing that can be a scum tell. Chop did claim a targeted lightning rod/bodyguard style role.

Mojoman: (leaning scummy) I've got a slightly scummy read on him. Granted he's been out of mafia for quite some time, but his post content is kind of lacking. It feels like activity to just check off the "town activity" checkbox. Mostly a null read but I'm suspiscious. Killing_You: (seems like scum) When I first started talking about a thief being in the game KY seemed to be a little too aggressive trying to get more information from me. Then he backed off once Shade started aggroing on me and started focusing on Shade. His behavior this day just strikes me as opportunistic. He's also been too quick to write off players as town. He's the scummiest read I have right now. OrangeP47: (leaning town) An enigma wrapped in an enigma... So far he's been pretty pro-town with trying to control information and scum hunt. For example, not wanting specific information on the infinity stones out there is the right thing to do. I don't see anything to indicate he's scum right now. But, that's been true of games where he is scum... I don't think there's even a remote reason to lynch him, but he's still worth keeping an eye on. FRAYDO: (seems like town) He's been pretty active and has actually been putting the pressure on players with some scum hunting. Based on that and his interactions with Irishman I'm thinking he's town. Brigitte: (null read) I don't think I've had any games with her, but all of her content is just spam. Somehwat active but seems to be activity for the sake of activity. Null read. ChopBam: (null-scum read) He's been fairly active this game. But in terms of actual content from him, it feels kind of week. He's mostly just made jabs at other players. Mostly a null read, but leaning towards scummy. TheIrishMan: (neutral or third-party) At this point I'm fairly certain he isn't town. Whether his interest align with ours or not is up for debate. If we're out of ideas we could always try a second lynch... But I don't think that would be productive. Louis: (null read) I haven't played with him before either and I don't see much actual content from him yet. I've got a null read on him. Shade939: (somehow town) Well, I would have a scum read on him. But he's now confirmed town. Now, let's talk about Cat5's death. Looking back at his D1 posts, the only realy content he had was calculating what would happen on a D1 lynch. He didn't actually build a case against anybody. Mafia killing him doesn't put suspicion on anybody, nor does it take pressure off of anybody. Either they killed him randomly (which I doubt) or they killed him because he was an experienced player and they knew he was not-mafia. With that in mind, I think we ought to consider a KY, ChopBam, or Mojoman lynch today. I would definitely want to see a read list from the last two though. @Mojoman @ChopBam Also, if anybody who has experience playing with Brigitte or Louis could chime in that would be appreciated. Not sure if this is how they usually play.

Yeah, I'm about ready to stop responding to him.

No, I'm town. Pretty sure I already said this?

Yeah... I'm not lynchproof. However, do you know who's usually lynchproof? Neutral/TP with an anti-town agenda.

Shade, you're tunneling me for bad reasons instead of hunting scum. This is seriously deja vu. If it weren't for your mod confirmed alignment I'd want to lynch you.

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/19z8uIcGzH_g0werM6JEwG10EPD40-_TAlWzJveZ78V4/edit#gid=997067778 Just take a look at my role that game...

It doesn't matter what I say to you, you will assume whatever you want.

What does my ability have to do with clearing a player? You can't make me clarify it.

@Killing_You Could you clarify on your ability a bit more for your target? This could help us clear you and another player.

Yes... As I've explained before it would be used to counter a thief. I think an experienced player could narrow down what I do to just two or three possibilities with what I've given. But there's enough uncertainty that the thief won't know for sure what I do.

Wrong. I said I have an ability that could be used against a thief. I've been very careful with my words not to reveal too much.

I do not have, and have not had, an infinity stone.

We know beyond a doubt that Shade is town. We also know that he used an infinity stone to steal a passive roleblock ability, based on the wording of this ability we can safely assume it was scum. This is a very powerful ability and it is reasonable to assume that they would try to find some way they could use it without causing suspicion after Shade's reveal. So we have ChopBam claiming to have been blocked by visiting Shade and FRAYDO claiming to have blocked Irish. I think that FRAYDO and Irishman are colluding together to make it seem like FRAYDO has a roleblock ability. Shade confirmed a mafia ability that roleblocks on a visit and FRAYDO claims that he roleblocked Irishman with one of his abilities. Just seems awfully convenient to me. I also don't buy the town, unlynchable, super watcher claim for a single moment. Especially when we have a dayvig who was mod confirmed. I think that Irish is either scum or a neutral who will pick a side (and probably already has). Either way, he's not good for town but there's probably nothing we can do to get rid of him. So that leaves FRAYDO who has been very quiet this game. I don't think Irish is town, which makes him a threat. I've also been a bit suspicious of FRAYDO; maybe my meta is rusty but he seems more reserved than usual. Any thoughts on this? I'm barely able to stay awake, hopefully I made this coherent.

Sorry, dosed up on Nyquil and barely able to stay awake. Still working on it.

Alright, we'll see what the others say. I think I've picked up on something that could lead to at least one scum today. Just need to see the other targets.

Would you mind sharing once everybody else has mad their claims? This could be important.

@TheIrishman I might have missed it, but did you intend to target anybody last night even though you were blocked?

Cat5: unknown, dead Shade: random, targeted mafia Irish: unknown, blocked Mojoman: unknown iLikeToSnipe: self-targeted Louis: nobody ChopBam: Shade, failed FRAYDO: blocked Irish Orange: unknown Killing_You: unknown Brigitte: unknown

@Mojoman @OrangeP47 @Killing_You @Brigitte I do NOT want to know your ability. I just want to know who, if anyone, you targeted last night. I've got a scummy feeling about something, but I need to be sure of who certain people targeted. To start, I self-targeted with my ability last night.

Yeah, based on my other ability I'm pretty sure knowing the name does nothing for stealing.

I'd actually rather keep the stones secret. I at least trust Shade to tell us the truth about the stones. Might be useful for verifying claims down the road if it stays hidden.