iLikeToSnipe

I'm not quite a ghost... Something far worse. Oh, bring back my Bonnie to me...

The singing will continue until morale is ruined. My Bonnie lies over the ocean...

If you've got a problem with it I could give you a visit tonight... My Bonnie lies over the sea...

It does seem like a fairly useless tool. But it's better than nothing for the beginning of D1. That is one thing I miss in forum games though; you can't really grill a person like in real life if you're playing this as a party game. My Bonnie lies over the ocean...

Does asking this ever actually work in a forum game? Just curious, cause I've used it in a party game to great effect before. Can't imagine it works too well on a forum. Oh, bring back my Bonnie to me...

I am not scum. Are you scum? My Bonnie lies over the ocean...

Shade for secondary scum? My Bonnie lies over the sea...

@Jeod Are you scum? My Bonnie lies over the ocean...

D1 lynch or bust!

Diplomacy would be a good game to start with. Involves alliances, backtabbing, etc.

MAFIA REUNION GAME LET'S GO!

Sign me up!

I think you ought to look at post to player ratio per game day/phase. Might give some more insight.

What Shade just mentioned about Irish having a double vote. I can't look it up due to time, but you also made some huge leap between exhonerating yourself as scum because you couldn't be the killer. The thing about Irish is just wild speculation.

Unfortunately I'm stuck in meetings with only a few minutes between them... Been a hectic two days at work. I think we ought to lynch Jeod or Orange. Been trying to keep up throughout the day, Jeod and Orange were both making some weird logical leaps. My gut says Jeod is the scum right now.

##unvote Too close to hammer

If there is a counter claim in flavor I'd prefer we start with the confirmed power role. There's a good chance scum only get one power role in this game, so the vanilla scum makes the kill and the blocker goes out and does his thing. Orange would have been one of my picks to block or kill as scum. ##vote Jeod

I'm not accusing you of being the first to support a nolynch. Just supporting an early no lynch. The early part is the key difference there. A nolynch itself can do that, but not an early nolynch. I can't think of a single benefit to a D1 early nolynch.

If our time is so vital why were you in favor of an early no lynch?

That's my bad, I'm super tired and just used to the "magic 10 number" of mafia signups. That only changes the odds though, not the logic.

It started yesterday with talking about an early nolynch on D1. Then he further dug into it when I asked him about it today. I think of Orange as a smart, veteran player. Losing information is not good for town. That still doesn't make sense... there's 9 players left, 2 of which are almost certainly scum. If we want to find the killer removing you makes it a 1 in 8 chance. But we don't want to just find the killer, we want to find scum. You are not cleared of being scum, you are cleared of being the killer. Therefore, with our objective as town it does not make sense to remove you from the lynch pool today.

Could you expand on that logic? Cause I don't see it.

I guess that is one thing... I trust that Jeod is a roleblocker. Doesn't mean that he's town, just makes it a bit more likely.

From my perspective I don't see that as town cred at all. You can't be the scum who killed Cat5, but there's nothing to indicate you weren't the scum who didn't. I'm inclined to trust Jeod for now, would be a pretty big gambit for a Jeod/Orange scum team.

I would assume with this being a basic game we'd have two scum with these numbers. You are cleared of not killing Cat5, not cleared of being scum.