Several things are on my mind.
I'm more and more convinced you are Town, but your possession of the 1Up is too significant to just look over. If I am to take you as Town, I have to really convince myself that the 1Up was indeed just given to you randomly, but that just can't be. If you didn't murder Verti he must have passed it to you and that was his mechanic of doctoring at work (i.e. if you were the victim of the NK that 1Up would have saved you). The fact that you claim you cannot pass it though disproves that theory entirely, and I'm still having a hard time taking it at your word that it was just put in your inventory. You also have not claimed to have just started with it either, or I would have accepted that statement at face value. Today you have done a good job of taking away my confidence in you as Scum, but in responding to the questioning of the 1Up you're just so shifty.
Seeing iLTS and KY placing their vote on Cat5 worries me. Cat5 has convinced me with his role claim that he is Town, though my masonry buddies must want me to follow their vote and cast mine on Cat5 anyway. I just can't do it. They both really can't be the remaining scum, can they?
Cat5 is all over the place with his votes, and while today I gained more confidence in him he is certainly taking away less and less before I have even finished this post.
Mojoman and Louis. Mojoman has to be Town. A player of dubious reputation in this game since D1, now left with nothing as a Vanilla role, and yet a target of opportunity all the same, I can't help but think his uselessness is rather useful for Scum. It's just too easy to vote him off, but why waste the NK on him when he has claimed Vanilla and no items.
Louis. If I'm to believe ChopBam is scum, then Louis is scum. With my current thinking now going to a Town ChopBam, and whether or not this is manipulation at its finest, I'm now thinking Louis is really Town.
Paranoia is a hell of a drug.