Retaliation

There are two things I'm interested in right now before I report. A) What were your results jeod. I assume you watched me. B) We've had a decrease in world tension. Does this imply shade's ability actually worked? Was Irish his target like he said?

So uh. I've had an interesting night.

So with a confirmed third party we can start considering there are only 2 scum. With 8 players alive, tomorrow we'll have 7 and with 3 scum I believe we would be in MYLO. Nodlied - Not much to go on. Busy, but still bottom middle activity. Involved in voe's death. Jeod - Is town or will be the death of me. It is worth noting that he could have easily just let me or FRAYDO die if scum. TheIrishman - Responsible for the death of his dear president. Hard to read because he's a competent player. ChopBam - I've not really gone over his posts, but I get the same vibe I got from cat5 and him in the game I was scum. Lots of little helpful things. Killing_You - Probably not scum based on flavor and Shade's statements. Shade would have to be lying both about his role and KY's alignment Shade - Pretty variable play. I'm inclined to believe him. It's a weird claim that I wouldn't expect scum to come up with. Should probably still question him. Retaliation - Mojoman - We have next to nothing here. Very little participation, but an obscure canadian flavor claim.

We’re just going to have to live with thinking the other is scum for eternity

I do not. When he's been around he's been pretty helpful and I feel has kept me level headed. This is where I'll have to switch to phone so responding will get harder.

Honestly makes me question if FRAYDO is actually scum.

He's scum. He knows I'm telling the truth. The moment I die a huge target is on his back and scum likes to lie low.

You guys demanded I start talking. Irish at least along with shade. Can't remember who else. So I started talking about what was on my mind i.e. how targeting cat5 was a huge mistake. I don't know if you notice but it's the end of day 2 and we're only on page 13. The activity this game has been super low, and I was fine with talking to get other people to talk.

Oh yeah autopsy has to be a dead player. So once again useless. Wasn't even allowed to find out what REALLY killed Kennedy. No everything is unlimited use. One time use was something I said in hopes that scum wouldn't think I'm a threat. The nugget of truth is that I targeted cat5 that night, and I did it to figure out his alignment.

Actually come to think of it autopsy is probably just as capable of nailing scum. How many townies have night kills or abilities that raise world tension?

Literally what I said. Every night I can uncover the target's alignment or what abilities they've used. I don't see a use for autopsy even if we just get the ability name.

I was basically making stuff up as I was going along KY. I wasn't willing to take the risk of outing myself as a cop when I didn't know if I have any support. So when I mentioned the big mistake I made (in hindsight not that big since a cop should sanity check anyway) and you started fishing for my role, I outlined the broad strokes in hopes of defusing it and downplaying my threat to scum. Ultimately didn't happen so here we are.

I was probably going to just role claim right around now anyway.

The primary source of information in mafia is lynch votes. They're public actions that help reveal what everyone's after. Speaking of lynch votes we haven't given nodlied enough trouble for being part of the voe lynch. I even forgot he was part of that.

Oh. That's true. Cop for scum is a trade I'm willing to take. I am the cop. My first ability is questioning and reveals the target's alignment. Night one I targeted cat5 forgetting that he's also a high priority night kill. Basically I was lying through my teeth because I didn't want to reveal my role and if it made me suspicious I wouldn't be a night kill target. My second ability is actually useless. I preform an autopsy which tells me the actions a player has made. Maybe there's a delayed killer or something? I know I'm sane because I got a town result on cat5.

I am not a vigilante.

I should rephrase. I don't think experienced players could come up with a role like that early on and be consistent about it, let alone new players.

Shade has said too many things that don't make sense without his roleclaim, and I don't think experienced players have it in them for such a long term play.

We have 3 declared soviet players. I (we if I'm lynched) know that neither KY or I am your target. So there's a fourth soviet player when everyone has declared. Oh I see what you mean. I meant to say all scum have declared themselves as not soviet. Originally wrote all scum have declared themselves as american, but mojo could be scum as well.

##vote FRAYDO Guess it's time to put my money where my mouth is. Here's my rough analysis if I'm lynched. All scum have declared themselves as something other than american (if not shade is lying) Chopbam is likely town because he's posting in that generally helpful way that reminds me of Cat5. He's also not gotten very much pushback suggestive that people are reluctant to actually defend FRAYDO. It is very risky for scum to defend scum after all (makes an obvious connection and scum already has a hard time getting into a town mindset) I'm assuming Jeod is town because FRAYDO thinks it's important that Jeod is town. Could also mean Jeod is scum (makes a risky connection) This leaves FRAYDO - Case has kind of been presented Nodlied - Haven't really looked into him. Irish - President of the Dead Kennedys fan club. Mojo - Claims canadian, but also claimed before it was obvious this is a very US vs Soviet centric game. Our missing captain?

So uh, I pretty much just repeated chopbam's argument looking back

I can't remember chopbam's reasoning on FRAYDO so I'll do a bit myself. Fraydo has made 7 posts since game start. 4 can't be separated from cosmic background radiation leaving us with these 3. So a lot of "I'm American and so is Chopbam so he's scum", but without any elaboration WHY chopbam has to be scum. We have 5 american claims. It hasn't been figured out that our "soviet" scum is LARPing as an American. Why is he so certain that he only needs to know two alignments (when there could easily be 3 american townies)? I'm describing my argument badly but in essence I feel like FRAYDO is arguing as if he knows how scum is distributed.

4 soviets with one scum means that 25% of soviet players are scum. I like it when math works out like that. I think I'm also liable to believe you because you've been pretty insistent about there being 4 soviet players and another officer. ##unvote For now... Premier Khrushchev, I have a report from the field! Our agents in Cuba believe that this crisis is caused by the inherent greed caused by capitalism, and we can expect to find the warmongers amongst those who have declared for it's greatest advocate: America!

I'm writing a post on the potential that there's no soviet scum players (TL;DR All the soviet roles are wierd choices for scum although Arkhipov is just a different choice away from being a warmonger).

Shoe is official soviet business Amerikanski scum.