Shade939

The other part of that is the NK fails if it hits the player the Doctor is protecting, so Mafia want to avoid targeting the same player and they have no idea who the Doctor is protecting that night. The mere chance the Cop is immune to the NK helps protect them.

Not particularly. IF we have a lynch today, then with a NK, we have 5 players starting tomorrow, and game will end with a MYLO. If we don't' do lynch today, then with a NK, we have 6 players starting tomorrow, and we're be at LYLO instead. Although, looking at that, we could do two no lynches instead. And push thing to a Day 3 LYLO, with 2 cop reports, and 2 dead players.

Of course, that only works if the Doctor can actually self protect? @Jeod

I think that's actually a fairly good argument for a day one role claim in this setup?

Except if scum claim a power role, then they can be counterclaimed by the actual power role, so we have a guaranteed 50% chance to get scum then. Primarily, power roles can actually claim if we're about to lynch them, even if Scum known who the Cop and the Doctor are, there's still the entire WIFOM argument about who the Doctor is protecting that night to deal with. In fact, it might even be better, since that would be a 50% chance for the Doctor to prevent he lynch instead then.

Game ends with Mafia tie Town, so if we skipped a lynch today, then Mafia could do a NK tonight, we lynch the wrong player tomorrow, and then the games over during that same night phase with another successful NK. And doctor only has something like a 33% chance of preventing a NK successfully.

We should actually have a lynch today given this setup. That'll basically give us a guaranteed two day lynches instead of one if we don't have one today.

And you're still happy with the reasoning for the other two votes?

So, we have three random votes on KY, and not much in the way of an explanation for most of them...

Either that or we have some really hard meta-gaming going on here. Also, I"m calling it now, but watch us lose the cop before they can report anything like usually seems to happen in these open setup games.

That was also my initial thought upon reading that statement. It's certainly does stand out.

Feels appropriate to have a day one vote on KY.

That's going to throw things off a bit. Well, time to sit back and see what happens regarding the usual metagame.

We have a miller you say.

Game will probably start tomorrow since we have six players with Killing_You and Mojoman.

A single day lynch isn't much of a game.

Yeah, I think you could easily get multiple people interested in it. Quite a few of us play over complicated RPG or strategy games already. Main thing is you'd need to set it up so you have some sort of time limit to drive the story along so you're not stuck waiting on other players to post.

Unless you want to be a bounty hunter. I think quite a few if us accidentally picked that class for our initial character picks.

It occurs to me, but I also forget to message @Mojoman and @ChopBam about wanting to join since they were also in the last game. And I'll go ahead and message @Nodlied

I'm in, also, you might want to individually message people so they're actually notice someone posted in this thread. @Retaliation @OrangeP47 @Voe @iLikeToSnipe @FRAYDO @Killing_You @Category 5 Hurricane or @Louis if they wanted to join up now, since they were just in the last game. I figure some of you have better ways of getting a hold of @Sunflowerand @rubeci also than this forum.

Although, FRAYDO was trying to push the lynch unto iLTS instead in that scenario actually, instead of getting Mojoman lynched.

He would have been shooting himself in the foot by calling out Mojoman so early, but I doubt that we would have caught him after such a hard busing to counter that.

Also, I'm still clearly getting confused about the Mastermind and thinking they're the one who has to kill the Mafia team instead of the inverse of that...

Really, what she should have done was jump on Orange as the other Mafia member sooner, if you didn't make the NK, since there's only one player left besides her. Maybe, although I'd think the only argument would be for FRAYDO to actually be the Mastermind instead.