Jump to content

Category 5 Hurricane

VIPs
  • Posts

    5,037
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    34
  • Donations

    0.00 USD 

Everything posted by Category 5 Hurricane

  1. So who's running the next game? Did someone have a concept ready to go?
  2. On MU I've seen them make new profiles for players to sign in to, for that purpose. I saw them do it for one of their big mash games. Afterwards players were allowed to keep using those profiles as they liked. So the guessing games continued even after that game was over, including cases where players traded those profiles.
  3. Gotta say, I can't remember the last time a game has stressed me out as much as this one.
  4. It was a very strange game, but I think it turned out well.
  5. I'll restate that I didn't design my role like this. I actually had a different idea entirely. Using the Nosferatu and Silence tomes were backup ideas.
  6. Yeah, and I actually misinterpreted my own role and counted on it roleblocking a NK when it would just penalize the person who killed me.
  7. Also, @TheIrishman I was wondering when someone was going to start meta-gaming the fact that Jeod generally lets people choose alignments. I've been doing that quietly in all these games.
  8. And meanwhile mafia had the ability to evade/reflect that same daykill. Offensively I couldn't hurt mafia. Defensively I couldn't hurt town.
  9. Right, but if we're getting into the realm of timeline correcting, then it starts with Retaliations actions that night. In which case, if his action was recorded correctly, it would have been passed.
  10. Is passing it the first night I had it not fast enough?
  11. Why should I not been able to pass it?
  12. Given my role and the number of claimed defensives at the time, I was certain that there was an unstoppable kill. It's a bit silly to say that it was "obvious" that Retal killed him.
  13. For some reason it was easier to find the TPs than the Mafia in this game.
  14. Looks like most of the dead doc didn't have the game figured out, either.
  15. I understand that you thought the claimed wincon was unrealistic, but, as this game proved, such a thing can happen.
  16. There was a lot of weird, but I'm not going to blame Jeod for that, given that this is a CYOR. This one must have been very hard to put together.
  17. Haven't seen all the pieces of the puzzle yet, but this was sure a strange one.
  18. @Shade939, so were you actually town?
  19. Yeah, I just thought he eventually stopped on his own.
×
×
  • Create New...