On MU I've seen them make new profiles for players to sign in to, for that purpose. I saw them do it for one of their big mash games. Afterwards players were allowed to keep using those profiles as they liked. So the guessing games continued even after that game was over, including cases where players traded those profiles.
I'll restate that I didn't design my role like this. I actually had a different idea entirely. Using the Nosferatu and Silence tomes were backup ideas.
Also, @TheIrishman I was wondering when someone was going to start meta-gaming the fact that Jeod generally lets people choose alignments. I've been doing that quietly in all these games.
Right, but if we're getting into the realm of timeline correcting, then it starts with Retaliations actions that night. In which case, if his action was recorded correctly, it would have been passed.
Given my role and the number of claimed defensives at the time, I was certain that there was an unstoppable kill. It's a bit silly to say that it was "obvious" that Retal killed him.