Category 5 Hurricane

Ok, that's a good point, but then that brings us back to "it's odd that only one of the investigations had two possible answers"

We've only just met this person. We don't know her playstyle yet. The best mafia players actually go out of their way to do this. Talk a lot. Make a fuss. Drive discussion on your own terms.

Look, if you're going to make a case on Brigitte at this point, this is the only way it can work. Step 1: Scum knows investigation results are insane. Step 2: Investigations only show unique selections. Step 3: Scyther is revealed. Step 4: Claim to have a Scyther even though you don't. Step 5: When your teammate is found out and did an insane investigation, out yourself fully. Step 6: Use the insane investigation to clear your teammate of suspicion.

It could also be that some of the rosters have a lie. Besides my one wildcard, it would be a reasonable strategy for scum to lie about the pokemon they have if they only lie about the ones they think they won't use.

The simple fact that there are so many duplicates actually makes it weird that only one investigation marked a duplicate. Which is why I asked Brigitte to prove she has a Scyther.

But only one of those investigation reports actually announced a pokemon owned by more than one person.

That's why I asking, why does duplication matter? Almost everyone has 2 or more duplicates. What's your point?

I still consider Brigitte somewhat suspicious, (less so now than previously) but I find your reasoning flawed. Why does duplicates matter in this case? I appreciate the heal, though.

##trainer TheIrishman, Shade ##rocket KY, Brigitte Will be at work from here on out.

If I think you are town, I'm going to have to think you aren't lying about having a level 10 as a primary. How would you be able to beat KY with a level 10?

Brigitte, why did you go with a level 10 today?

Jeod, You, TheIrishman.

And perhaps hint that the scum team may not be linked.

If Jeod had a plan involving KY and KY is his teammate, that plan would have happened.

On the other hand, KY training up a Blastoise does heavily suggest he was training to counter Jeod.

We don't know that those results are insane. I'd feel more comfortable with that idea if the other two investigations pointed towards two different people, but they do not.

Maybe? I'm having trouble figuring out who KYs partner may be if it isn't Jeod and/or Brigitte.

Right, rockets had a slight battle advantage in the last game. Including a bigger stockpile of items, if I remember correctly. Don't remember if there was anything else.

Oh, right, I thought he was saying trainer as opposed to rocket. Attacking me for the role makes sense.

"the trainer?"

Yeah, I can handle it.

So, if they aren't linked yet, they must be sure I'm not on their team.

Which is kind of odd, I have to say.

Hitmonchan

Apparently scum doesn't like me so much. I was actually attacked last night, and one of my pokemon was taken down to half health.