Killing_You

My read right now is that he's trying a bit too hard to push the idea that Nodlied was neutral in order to get Orange lynched. It doesn't sit well with me. Huh? It's a Cop ability, not a Tracker. Also, no immunity that I can see.

If we're still stumped by the end of the day, sure. But we need to look at other possibilities as well.

PLAYER ROLE CLAIMED ALIGNMENT Killing You Armed Cop Town OrangeP47 Jailer Neutral Jeod Role Copy Machine Town iLikeToSnipe Vengeful Doctor Town Shade939 Jack-of-all-Trades Town Nodlied Hider Neutral Category 5 Hurricane Dead Whisperer Town ChopBam Tracker Town Sunflower Watcher Town Verti60 Lynchproof Town If I were to guess, I'd say that Nodlied may have been scum, and may have been bussed. I don't know; we have three dead players and no definitive confirmations on their alignments. Yesterday might warrant a much closer look.

Guilty =/= Scum, it seems. I thought he may have been scum or third party, depending on the situation. I'm making dinner right now and then I'll be spending some quality time with the lady, and then I'll be back to reassess the situation.

Of course Cat5. But if it'll get us to see flips... ##shoot Category 5

Well then... any objections from the rest of the town?

Wait really?

I'm a cop. Though I don't get normal "Town/Neutral/TP/Mafia" reports, just "Innocent" and "Guilty."

Neat. That doesn't explain how I got a Guilty result on you last night.

So if someone visits you, then the next night their target is switched, possibly without warning. This should mean that N4 my result should be swapped. Correct?

Riveting. But nothing that messes with investigation results of any kind?

@OrangeP47, please remind me. What is your alignment, and what are your abilities?

Something's not right here. There has to be something in play keeping us from seeing people's alignment and abilities on death.

Undead tends to range from ghosts to zombies, vampires to skeletons, wraiths to liches, etc... So I would say that vamps are generally undead. Holy water works on certain versions as well. They also generally don't do well in sunlight, ranging from being depowered to being turned to ash.

I agree.

Strongly considering it. My only concern is that it might be necessary to take out a hostile without repercussions, though if I was looking at the claims and my reads I don't suspect any of the BPs.

Where do you stand on the Nodlied situation? Specifically, do you buy his neutral hider claim (that kills undeads), and should I shoot him rather than lynching him?

Well, here's the thing... My takeaway is that Orange wants to keep jailing me out of obligation to keep me safe. He pretty much stated it outright. Not sure, if I'm being honest. But it's not enough for me to declare that one of the BPs is absolutely scum, only enough for me to kind of suspect them.

This isn't meant to poke holes in your argument, but I'd like to point out that we have had unlynchable scum in the past. It didn't end well, and I don't think Irish would do that. It was enough for us to stop going "unlynchable = town," but whether that was a good thing or not is debatable. I like this line of reasoning. Kind of glad that I didn't shoot you. Interesting plan. I'm going to wait a little bit for other people's input, but I'm personally on board. My main reason for holstering my shot is in case one of the claimed BPs was scum, but it looks like that's not the case. I'd also like to use it so that Orange doesn't feel obligated to jail me anymore.

I have to leave for a while, but suffice to say, I don't buy Nodlied's claim. ##vote Nodlied Neutral jailer sounds far more plausible to me than neutral hider with a killing edge. While I'm gone, I'll be considering how to use this shot. I'd rather not be jailed anymore.

One. So you're a pseudo-vig/flavor cop? Doesn't seem right to me, but I don't really have time to try and pick this claim apart right now.

Then why did you elect not to use it?

Cool. So that leaves three possibilities for the nightkill not happening N1, now that we have a nightkill and different targets to compare it to. 1. Nodlied tried to make the kill, but was blocked. 2. iLikeToSnipe tried to make the kill, but was blocked. 3. Someone tried to hit Nodlied N1, and went for Jeod N2. That third one strikes me as the least likely, since iLikeToSnipe mentioned that he'd probably protect Jeod. I meant to say "wasn't" on that second one. Damn my fingers. So I guess my next question would be, do you have a night action?

Undecided at the moment. I want to be a little bit more certain before I make my decision, but at the same time I definitely want to use it today so that Orange can focus on jailing other people. It does seem oddly coincidental that Nodlied was blocked N1 and there was no kill, yet he was blocked N2 and there was a kill. @Shade939 Please correct me if I'm wrong, but you blocked iLTS N1, correct?

Well, I woke up with a "fuzzy head" and my action failed, so I suppose this is confirmation. Not going to lie, though, I'm a bit annoyed. And as such, I'm not sure where to go from here. Some more information would be beneficial.