Jump to content

Killing_You

Staff Moderators
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    4,557

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    141

  • Donations

    0.00 USD 

 Content Type 

Everything posted by Killing_You

  1. Killing_You
    That seems a rather flimsy reason to vote him up. Is there any evidence beyond that?
  2. Killing_You
    I'm saying it's the only thing that could reasonably defend Voe. It's a long shot in any case.
  3. Killing_You
    Well, that's what I meant. If the sub pen is responsible for moving Voe, their testimony might be the only thing that saves him. If not, their silence will tell us all we need to know.
  4. Killing_You
    I'll probably place my vote closer to hammer, but right now I'm leaning towards Voe as well. I'd like to give him a chance to defend himself, as well as keep the possibility of a sub pen defense on the table.
  5. Killing_You
    Let's also not forget that I left an AFK vote on my teammate back in Warhammer. It almost cleared me, until I slipped up later. Also, Voe tends to be a power player in games that he plays. He's unusually quiet this round. My only concern is how he reacted to being moved (which is still a bit of a mystery), which seemed more town to me. That's actually a bit of a hole in this case. However, since we haven't had a Sub Pen claim to back it up, it's still up in the air.
  6. Killing_You
    Oh wow, that's an angle I hadn't considered. Nice going, Chop.
  7. Killing_You
    MAFIA EDIT: has* Dang it, drunken fingers.
  8. Killing_You
    And you just described what the Spy Plane had been doing the whole game.
  9. Killing_You
    Something just came to mind: If Town loses the airfield, we'll lose not only the Spy Plane (I assume), but the lynches as well. If this is the case, then we'd have to rely on blind fire and claimed positions to find scum, while scum would still have their scouting abilities. What would you suggest Town do in that situation?
  10. Killing_You
    So, why wasn't I hurt when I got tagged?
  11. Killing_You
    There's a few problems with this line of reasoning. First, it requires somebody to claim their coordinates. If you'll notice, very few of us have. If you use it only to confirm player's locations, and nobody has any location claims for you to confirm, what do you do? Sit on your hands? Second, even if you do get claims out of people, you can only check them one person per night. That's extraordinarily ineffective. Third, let's say that it was indeed a scum ability. Why would it show up for all of town to see? Looking at the role sheet in the OP... ...both the Gunboat and the Destroyer have scouting abilities. Yet, aside from Jeod's report of being pinged by the Sonar Pulse, we haven't seen evidence of either of those actions. Even then, Jeod's position was not revealed on the main map; he had to tell us that he was pinged. (And if I haven't said so yet, yes, I do believe that scum have a more complete map than us). Why, then, would the Spy Plane show up if it was a scum ability, yet the other actions wouldn't? I think Shade's throwing us off the trail. Perhaps purposefully.
  12. Killing_You
    What is it supposed to do? Not scout as to keep the Airfield hidden? Also, I'll go ahead and mention that I was notified when the Spy Plane scouted my position.
  13. Killing_You
    Nothing on my end, either.
  14. Killing_You
    Well, fair enough, I suppose. pls no hit me
  15. Killing_You
    That would be me. Why do you ask?
  16. Killing_You
    Point being?
  17. Killing_You
    I have a sneaking suspicion that Jack might be teamed with Shade. More on that later (as in, if Jack flips scum, I'll look into it more)
  18. Killing_You
    While we're here... @Alstar @FRAYDO Haven't heard from you two for a solid while. Any input?
  19. Killing_You
    Ninja'd by Jeod.
  20. Killing_You
    I'm not sure I buy this, tbh. It's not the flimsiest claim per se, but combined with the other evidence I doubt it's the truth. ##vote JackoDerp On the subject of that second part, where did you fire?
  21. Killing_You
    Fair enough.
  22. Killing_You
    Decent enough rebuttal, though I still wonder why it took so long for you to say so. Eh, not particularly vote worthy at this point anyway. ##unvote I agree that Voe would likely be notified if it was the sub pen's doing. I wish I had more leads to present, but alas, none come to mind.
  23. Killing_You
    Little late to the party there 😛
  24. Killing_You
    I want to take a closer look at this Cat5 thing. To me, this looks like Category 5 knew what happened, and tried to set up a case on whoever moved (in this case, Voe). Then, he seemed to realize that his setup was flimsy at best, and tried to backtrack in order to distance himself from the situation. These are all of the posts he made following his initial report. Trying to focus on the JackODerp situation while avoiding a pertinent question: How did he get the info? He hasn't even said something along the lines of "It's best if I keep it secret for the sake of Town," he's just avoided the question altogether. Currently, I think that Category 5 teleported Voe, tried to setup a scenario where moving is a scum ability, realized that it would be difficult to press such a case, and decided to backtrack before he got caught. If he's a tracker/watcher/similar, he wouldn't have avoided the question of how he got that info, nor would he have been so vague in his second post. If he's town and responsible for the teleport, he wouldn't have opened in a semi-accusatory way. ##vote Category 5 Hurricane
  25. Killing_You
    Yeah, I'm not contesting that. It just seems suspicious to me that Cat 5 reported that someone "has the ability to move," only to be followed by Voe reporting that he was teleported. He also hasn't stated how he knows this, which leads me to wonder if Cat5 is responsible.
×
×
  • Create New...