iLikeToSnipe

@Jeod This is pretty important and I can't make this post until I get an answer from you.

@Jeod I've found an interesting train of logic here... and I need an answer from you. You claim to have watched yourself last night. What was the flavor of that? Did it explicitly state who you were watching?

Interesting that there was no kill after you visited the guy who's NK immune.

Reread my post. To spell it out more clearly I'm the bullet proof role I requested.

Nothing, because my night "action" is to stay nice and comfy.

I will confirm I was visited last night.

If you really do have this ability I don't see a reason not to use it today. If we use it right we'll do one or more of the following items: Clear somebody as being not-mafia and prove part of Jeod's role claim Prove your role claim Get a mafia member and give you some extra charges to repeat this process Now, we should absolutely not rush through to pick a primary lynch target without discussion. I do have a bunch of questions I want to ask people as well as some more detailed thoughts to post but I still haven't had time to put it all together. I should be back in about 2-3 hours but I'll be able to skim posts on mobile.

I've had some stuff come up unexpectedly and won't be back for about 3 hours. In the meantime, here's what I've been thinking. Jeod has claimed that he's lynchproof and Orange has claimed that he can manipulate a double lynch. What I'd like to do is for us to settle on a primary suspect for a lynch today. We'll setup the votes so that, as Jeod had talked about earlier, we have a 3:2 vote ratio. Most of our votes will go on this suspect and the rest will go on Jeod. If Orange is lying then we know who our target is for D3. This will also test Jeod's lynchproof claim if we our suspect happens to be non-mafia. The end result is that we have a relatively risk-free lynch that will test the claims of up to three people. Anyways, I'll be leaving in a few minutes, let me know what you all think.

inb4 there's no mafia

I've gotten sidetracked with work and personal projects, I probably won't be back to post until about 2-3 hours after start of D2. I think we're going to be able to make some progress.

Well, I'm going to look through everything and hopefully have time to write up a big wall of text. Even though we had a nolynch today I still think we can make a lot of progress tomorrow.

Well this has been a great day...

"It's justified, but it's not what I want."

It's rather convenient now that you're at a coin toss for staying alive and waiting till the last second.

I don't like this... It would provide an excuse for just about anything that happens tonight. "I didn't mean to visit X, he must have been swapped." Also, interesting point Orange.

I've got a present for ya.

I have donuts. I also will have packzis soon.

In my opinion, there are no 3rd party roles that are pro-town. Some of them can be considered neutral, but they're in this for themselves and will stab us in the back if it'll save them. So, while it's a greater chance that he's scum than 3rd party, I don't think it's worth it in the off chance that he is 3rd party. If he's 3rd party then we get a no lynch and just know that he's less lethal than scum. I think it would be a waste of resources for an ~85% chance that you get a bonus charge. If he is 3rd party, you lose that ability and we lose the opportunity to use it tomorrow. This is a 10 player game iirc, we're not getting too many days out of this so there's not much margin for error.

We know that there's something scummy about Shade. He hasn't claimed some amazing power role that could make us hesitant about lynching him without a safety net. Besides that, I think we can maximize his utility tomorrow.

Why not both?

Scum! No way do we have the same ability.

Sorry, was in line and then got to the front of the queue suddenly. I made a post back on page 13 I think summarizing what I found against Shade.

I can't do too much unfortunately since I'm on mobile. Shade made some scummy slips and is most certainly not town.

What he's done is not related to the meta of "overpowered role". Neither of those arguments correlate. I think his initial actions are suspicious, but he hasn't done anything to identify himself as not being town.