Abbreviated post, don't have time to retype everything.
I can confirm one player as town. Will not list who or why, don't want to put them in danger. I'm also fairly certain that FRAYDO is not scum. Could still be anti-town, but he's off the list.
I'd like @OrangeP47 and @FRAYDO to weigh in on ChopBam's claims. Could narrow the list even more.
With that being said, we're at about 6 players who could have done the night kill. Of those 6, I have a decent town read on Irishman. If we take Orange off the list for now we're down to 4 players. Looking at those four and the reactions today I strongly suspect that the attempted killer is Shade.
He was very vocal against my attempts to find scum. I'm going to read through his posts tonight and probably cast a vote then.