TheIrishman

Just searched, his opinion of me changed around D10-12.

Jeod was a Follower type Tracker, so he could see the action performed by his target. He saw my action and through it determined me to be Town. I don't remember where exactly, but it was around page 7-ish I think.

I was already confirmed Town by Jeod and through the PM ordeal, I'd rather not put a target on my back.

I considered the target switcher as thief 2 since he essentially helped steal the items Cat5 dropped, even if they didn't go to him.

It looks like the scum teams are coming together. My two suspected team comps are FRAYDO, OrangeP47, and Killing_You or Retaliation, OrangeP47, and Chaos_Knight. Killing_You and Mojoman are the main variables and the ones I'm least confident to pick between. Players Nationality Status Items Evidence Role Town/Scum % Jeod American Town Dead (Typewriter) (Grenade) None Reporter Tracker 100/0 Category 5 Austrian “Suspicious” “Spyglass” Unknown Navy Officer? 80/20 TheIrishman Bosnian Innocent Unknown None that I know of Unknown 100/0 FRAYDO Serbian Suspicious None Black Hand Book (Thief 2) 20/80 Mojoman Serbian “Innocent” Telephone Colt “No Evidence” “Locked till X%” (Thief 1 or 2) 40/60 Chaos_Knight Serbian Suspicious None More Black Hand stuff “Tracker” 50/50 Killing_You Bosnian Unknown (Grenade) Unknown (Thief) 40/60 Verti60 Serbian Innocent None None “Backup” 95/5 OrangeP47 Austrian “Suspicious” “BP Vest” “No Evidence” “Protector” (Killer) 25/75 Retaliation Hungarian “Suspicious” Something Unknown "Roleblocker” 70/30

Well, the Black Hand had Serbians fighting against themselves, so it would stand to reason that there would be a some good Serbians and some/a bad Serbian{s}.

I don't understand where Retal could've claimed from the evidence that Austrians were part of the Black Hand. The Black Hand were Serbians.

But if Retal did actually roleblock Orange, then that leaves only Killing_You and Mojo as the potential thief. Provided Retal, CK, and Orange aren't a scum team.

##nominate Category 5 *

I don't see the point of changing our nominee to Vert. ##Category 5

It appears that Chaos's evidence is fake. With 10% for standard evidence and 6% for the true evidence in the truth box.

He said he was going to pass off an item, so you should have said item. Odd that no one was killed, especially since you say you were roleblocked. If you were roleblocked, then either you were because someone was trying to prevent you from protecting another, or someone roleblocked you to prevent you from killing anyone >.> So if that's the case we either have a Scum Roleblocker or Town Roleblocker. I'd be betting more towards a Town Roleblocker though seeing as no one has claimed to be roleblocked this entire game. Unless it's one of the locked abilities, which would point toward either Mojo or Retal. Though it'd most likely be Retal since Mojo already has a telephone and a colt. I'm a bit skeptic on Orange's roleblocked claim though. I mean, why would scum roleblock him if they could just kill him instead? So the most important things to hear now will be whether Orange gained an item and what Retal has to say.

*sigh* I still don't understand why all the suspicion on Vert. I already explained multiple times from a GM's point of view, putting him as scum wouldn't make sense. Yeah, he was a bit sketchy, but he wasn't entirely following along with the game to begin with. This, like Cat5, just makes me suspect the people who voted him even more. Updated Table. Players Nationality Status Items Evidence Role Town/Scum % Jeod American Town Dead (Typewriter) (Grenade) None Reporter Tracker 100/0 Category 5 Austrian “Suspicious” “Spyglass” Unknown Navy Officer? 80/20 TheIrishman Bosnian Innocent Unknown None that I know of Unknown 100/0 FRAYDO Serbian Suspicious None Black Hand Book Unknown 20/80 Mojoman Serbian “Innocent” Telephone Colt “No Evidence” “Locked till X%” 50/50 Chaos_Knight Serbian Suspicious None More Black Hand stuff “Tracker” 50/50 Killing_You Bosnian Unknown (Grenade) Unknown Unknown 40/60 Verti60 Serbian Innocent “None” “None” “Backup” 95/5 OrangeP47 Austrian “Suspicious” “BP Vest” “No Evidence” “Protector” 25/75 Retaliation Hungarian “Suspicious” Something Unknown “Locked till X” 70/30

Fun stuff. I'm good with moving the hammer ahead by an hour.

Are you saying you do have an alibi? An alibi isn't useless if it can't be confirmed initially. Who knows, there might be someone who can either corroborate your story or prove it to be false at a later time.

Congrats Collective Soul...I've never heard any music and felt the base so clearly from 2 miles away and with a river and creek separating us. >.> (just a general complaint) Well Orange, I feel like the main problem is that you've been too indecisive, always taking the "wait and see" approach. Which seems scummy. When added atop being one of the suspects of being the thief, leaving the other ones to be CK (who can potentially prove he's not), KY (who already gave up his grenade), and Vert (who claims backup with solid reasoning for the claim), it makes you the most suspicious.

You're excusing yourself from that list >.> There's still the chance of you being in cahoots with CK, albeit, it'd be lower provided things play out well.

Cat5, the problem with the second point is that if CK is scum, whether we give him the list or not, there's the possibility of him claiming he targeted his scum buddy. At least if we give him a list of targets, there's a lesser chance he'll be able to target his scum buddy. Although we could have him target you or me to confirm our actions, but that requires us to accept the loss of potential information gained from him tracking possible scum.

Not to a specific target, but a pool of maybe 4 would be good so they're not sure it's them. And the first thing I want for D4 is his report. I'd rather he not have the ability to try and fit in his "target" according to what other people have said. I would put OrangeP47, FRAYDO, Killing_You, and Retaliation as our most viable targets.

I just figured with both sets of evidence pointing towards nationalities, in this case Serbians, that they probably have a use in discerning truth of evidence. For example, if we get a piece of evidence mentioning that our thief was [Insert Nationality Here] then we could use that.

In hindsight, I wish he didn't point out that he was the tracker, but I can't really blame him. If there were 2 kill free nights in a row, I'd probably drop my guard a bit too.

Hammer is tomorrow...

I doubt Cat5 would be killed. He has no power right now and that makes him the ideal candidate to enter the vault. The less power he has, the less of a threat he is to scum.

##nominate Category 5 I feel more comfortable with you being the one to enter the vault. I can't trust Retaliation enough for it and I don't see a need for me to enter yet. Right now I'm thinking the scum team is FRAYDO, OrangeP47, and Retaliation. Although next guess is KY over CK. Just because that grenade still makes me wonder if it was placed in the vault in hopes that Town would use it and raise WT. It'd only allow you the opportunity if nothing went wrong. Your idea is me nominating someone I think to be scum aligned into an important and potentially dangerous position with only the possibility of it not blowing up in my face.

Huh, the rest made their decision on FRAYDO or OrangeP47 before I knew it. ##investigate OrangeP47