Jump to content

Category 5 Hurricane

VIPs
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    5,037

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    34

  • Donations

    0.00 USD 

 Content Type 

Everything posted by Category 5 Hurricane

  1. Category 5 Hurricane
    How would you know what the TP victory condition is?
  2. Category 5 Hurricane
    I still don't really understand your case on Retaliation. Which is to say I don't remember hearing one at all.
  3. Category 5 Hurricane
    Technically we don't know. Typical anti-town (including Mafia and TP together) percentages range from 20% on the low end and 30% on the high end.
  4. Category 5 Hurricane
    Depending on context, I guess. For wagonomics, not really.
  5. Category 5 Hurricane
    Yeah, but to a much lesser degree than in a majority lynch game. Only late votes really have much weight.
  6. Category 5 Hurricane
    I dunno, without having majority hammer, anyone can vote at any time and it's meaningless unless it's their last vote.
  7. Category 5 Hurricane
    I remember a scum player only posting twice during D1 and then never again winning, because everyone assumed he was not playing.
  8. Category 5 Hurricane
    Stalling the game isn't so bad, given scum having a time limit.
  9. Category 5 Hurricane
    Be careful, you might be tempted to design a 5 or 6-sided mafia game based on Three Houses by the time you're done with that.
  10. Category 5 Hurricane
    We're way too in sync again.
  11. Category 5 Hurricane
    Right, which is why FRAYDO is right that with the position he is in, he's the default lynch regardless of which alignment he actually is. We can't start knocking the logic dominoes down until we get a flip from somewhere. Unless you want to start with Louis's lynch, I suppose.
  12. Category 5 Hurricane
    Or, on the flipside, if FRAYDO really is town, the ones making the noise about him being town might be the ones who know that he is.
  13. Category 5 Hurricane
    It's mostly annoying to me, because before Coolrock confirmed my suspicions that he tried to target Louis, I did have an alternative theory that would have fit perfectly with what we know.
  14. Category 5 Hurricane
    Choosing the "emotional" side means choosing an alternative theory. Maybe not a specific one, but it does mean that you are rejecting the one that has been laid out.
  15. Category 5 Hurricane
    I think I used too many negatives in that statement, but whatever. Thing is that an alternative could be presented, but nobody is doing it.
  16. Category 5 Hurricane
    It's not like FRAYDO isn't a player who can't appear innocent when he's not. There is no way I'm accepting this argument without a plausible alternative.
  17. Category 5 Hurricane
    Make the case. Currently it appears FRAYDO was roleblocked and that is why the NK didn't happen. State what you think happened instead.
  18. Category 5 Hurricane
    Wowza
  19. Category 5 Hurricane
    But honestly I think you are correct, in that I think he is a Spy.
  20. Category 5 Hurricane
    IT VERIFIES NOTHING OTHER THAN HE CAN'T BE A SILO OR RADAR TOWER
  21. Category 5 Hurricane
    BORING. I wanted him to claim "I'm actually a Silo!" and then get a stuck result.
  22. Category 5 Hurricane
    Oh, I'm starting to hope for a plot twist but I don't know if my heart could take it if what I just thought of is true.
  23. Category 5 Hurricane
    No, because he said he tried to help someone.
  24. Category 5 Hurricane
    I think FRAYDO should have been looking at Coolrock as the "real" reason why the NK didn't happen. To suggest that neither he or Coolrock attempted the NK means that the scum team failed to NK without being interfered with.
  25. Category 5 Hurricane
    I would agree with you if FRAYDO didn't have a shaky reaction to the events.
×
×
  • Create New...