Jump to content

Category 5 Hurricane

VIPs
  • Posts

    5,037
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    34
  • Donations

    0.00 USD 

Everything posted by Category 5 Hurricane

  1. Anon_Kat didn't really count as a player, let's be real.
  2. The voting analysis wound up being correct, but not for the reasons I was thinking. And I pretty much included the stats in the dead doc. 46% chance Shade was Spy, 8% chance FRAYDO was Jailer, all following the math. You can't rely on it.
  3. He couldn't be a spy, he had fired a shot and it didn't jam. I tried signaling that to you, if you hadn't thought of it.
  4. I thought Chopbam was softing cop. And thinking he was softing a town investigation on iLTS, I was believing iLTS town even though my vote analysis suggested he wasn't.
  5. Would be a bad time to start a new long form mafia game.
  6. Why wouldn't you assume that it just meant I couldn't target someone else? Or, what if I was the one jailed?
  7. Well, the fact that iLTS accidentally put himself in position to be counterclaimed by two people at the same time pretty much screwed them, after Jeod pretty much screwed himself, probably matters more than anything else.
  8. Being obsessed with statistics in this game just somewhat helps scum find power roles, though that whole process counts on shots being fired. Once a power role has fired, their value to kill automatically decreases, so really it doesn't do a whole lot. For town obsessing over statistics helps find out who could be scum, and also might inform on who scum might decide to nightkill. Much more useful.
  9. Look, even with Shade, an alive town is better than a dead town. I know that's heavily debatable, but that's my position on it.
  10. I say that, but I still count Voe among my stronger town reads. And Shade, for that matter.
  11. Yes, Shade, that's how you properly use the math. If Jeod comes up scum, the cop probably doesn't even need to claim.
  12. The GM must have lied. TheIrishman's weapon stuck, he's a spy!
  13. I don't understand it. Perhaps if he indicated he wasn't going to say more, you could have gone for it then. There wasn't much reason to hurry.
  14. I don't want to hammer it yet, but yeah, nolynch is probably the way to go now, if for no reason other than to get us back on "schedule" so that the game ends on day phase.
  15. Yeah, that sudden target selection without any discussion was pretty suspect, even though I know you are short on time.
  16. He's got a while. Well, if he's just on break he might not have that much time.
  17. Given the known available roles, there is probably only one thing that could serve as an alibi.
  18. I feel like we need to start including common mechanics questions like that in the OP before the game starts, just to get it out of the way.
×
×
  • Create New...