Category 5 Hurricane

If it comes down to it that I need to be lynched just to have my story verified, though, I'm fine with that. We likely have plenty of time, and my usefulness is pretty limited at this point.

And then as far as anyone else that eventually cased and voted for Jeod, if Jeod felt he was going down for some reason, any teammate could be directed to turn on him for town cred. That fairly applies to me, but at the same time it applies to anyone else.

Irish isn't cleared himself, so why are you taking his word as golden? Louis is clearing Retaliation, but there are roles that allow unstoppable kills, so she could jail him and still get attacked by him. There are also roles that activate passively, though I guess whether a jailor would bypass those things would depend on the GM.

Sure, that's possible, assuming mafia can't use it's abilities and kill at the same time. It's also possible that literally anybody else did it, including Retaliation, if he has a way to bypass a roleblock. It's also possible that Louis is lying about being attacked. Having been last to report, I also could have said anything else, if I wanted to lie about it.

You have a severe lack of imagination. There isn't anybody I see that can be absolutely ruled out, just on a logical case. This isn't a open setup, you do not know what is possible.

No, you aren't getting more details about my role. I just stated I'm not listing my limitations.

I'll forgive the rest of this case, because it's fair to consider alternatives, but please consider that the timing of the vote might have to do with when I'm sleeping and when I'm at work. I slept on the case, went to work, and then finally voted when I was on break and had to make a decision between going for the logical case on TheIrishman or the behaviorial case on Jeod. Voting isn't a race. I generally only vote when I have to, or there is no uncertainty in my case.

My report is that I didn't swap anybody. I don't really want to give away my limitations, but I'll just say I can't do that every night. @ Louis Very surprising that you blocked Retaliation instead of TheIrishman.

The really confusing part to me is that Jeod walked himself into this by claiming he was jailed, when he almost certainly wasn't. Even if he actually was, he never had to admit to it. He could have stayed quiet and not gotten nearly as much suspicion as he did. This had to be an attempt to cover for something.

Yeah, I'm not convinced. This has to be a short post as I'm at work, but Jeod's story doesn't make sense to me. I still think he is lying about something, but I don't understand why he's using the story he has. I guess we'll have to check TheIrishman after this. ##vote Jeod

Anyway, I've delayed going to bed long enough. Off for now.

Yes, well, I wonder.

@ Retaliation keeps quietly mumbling that he was going to take credit for stopping the NK. Is this where the mystery second jailer comes from?

I sort of feel like all the bullshit is a huge distraction, so I want to refocus on what we think we know. We know there wasn't a kill N1. We don't know why. Possibility #1 is that TheIrishman was going to do the kill and was stopped by Louis Possibility #2 is that TheIrishman was the target of the NK and protected by Louis (unclear if Louis's ability actually has this function, jailors don't always protect) Possibility #3 is that Jeod was going to do the kill and was stopped by ??? Possibility #4 is that Jeod was the target of the NK and was protected by ??? (again, unclear if this is actually possible) Possibility #5 is that Jeod targeted TheIrishman but was redirected back to himself. Possibility #6 is that mafia did not do a kill, and all this other stuff has nothing to do with it. Sorted more or less in the order I think it's possible, ignoring outside factors. I'm sort of assuming Louis is actually a jailor for all of this, otherwise the possibilities open up to just about anything and become worthless to think about.

I technically do not "know" you were jailed either. I just know Louis claimed to be a jailor that targeted Jeod, and I swapped Jeod with you, and you claimed to be jailed. Seems legit, but if the two of you are a team, it could be a double fake. So that scenario still works on you in reverse. But yes, rather outlandish, all outside factors considered. As far as a NK hitting mafia, that's another one of those things where it would be up to the GM to decide. Town bus drivers aren't popular because of that potential where mafia risks killing themselves and can't do much to stop it, (in a 3 person MYLO with a town bus driver, how does mafia win?) so usually mafia members are made immune from their own attacks. How that would be resolved in this case, I don't know. You could be correct as well, we wouldn't know the difference.

No, I was doing things and checking back occasionally, and I voted when I decided that you weren't going to say anything. The only time I saw you online was just after you were done with work.

Ok, I like this post, though I will point out that the idea that Jeod could have targeted TheIrishman also works in reverse, and this is one of the alternate theories I've been thinking about. ##unvote An extension of that is the NK might not have been blocked, but failed because it landed on a mafia player due to one of them being swapped. TheIrishman suggests BP, I figured that a NK directed onto a mafia member would just auto fail, but the result is the same. In this scenario, a mafia player is one of TheIrishman or Jeod, but not both, and the NK came from outside that loop.

Not exactly, I waited for you to say anything at all, and since you didn't I decided to vote for you. You sure have interesting timing. I don't think your name was even in the thread when I came in to post.

Ok @ TheIrishman , I've waited long enough. ##vote TheIrishman

I mean, I don't think it's a bad read. Just don't make the mistake of getting so zeroed in on one target that you can't accept other possibilities.

I'm waiting for TheIrishman to start talking, because there is actually still more possibilities as far as what actually happened last night.

I want to pressure him to talk, at least. Vote may come down to who we can agree on.

Eh, it's part of the confusing rules, having to remember that sometimes, GM confirmed information isn't actually true.

Yes, exactly.

Target was TheIrishman and Jeod. They switched places.