Category 5 Hurricane

If TheIrishman is Mafia and can enable lynchproof constantly, what other method would you suggest?

It could make him Third Party, though...

If he could just spam lynch protection, that would imply he is not scum, wouldn't it? Otherwise KY is always the only way he can be removed.

I don't get it either.

Well, it is what I was implying with the question, yes.

How do you know he's unkillable?

iLTS had a positive item in his possession and has freely tossed it around. Granted, the item forces you to pass, but unless you think that iLTS, TheIrishman, and myself are all scum, that item has been passed to players who are not on the scum team.

If it makes you feel better, I'm not saying I have enough reason to make a vote on either of you yet, I just have reason for suspicion. I'm in this strange place in my arguments right now where I have reason to suspect just about everyone, but also have town reads from just about everyone.

Forget that, you supposedly redirected a player to target someone he said publicly he was going to target.

No, I don't. As you know, the shop did not include descriptions. You had to trust what Shade told you things did.

Speaking of potential falsified covers: Didn't you supposedly purchase a Medkit?

Sure, KY "confirmed" your ability, but that makes 1 out of 4 supposed targets that can actually back up your story. The rest all have no idea. That is easily a falsifiable cover.

You're right, but that wasn't the point then, was it?

It's the sweater we were talking about earlier. iLTS passed it to TIM, I talked to TIM to verify the item characteristics and got seemingly different answers, and then he passed it to me.

There is nothing else to do on the website, afterall.

Of course I am. I'm playing mafia.

For what it's worth, he fully explained his role to me during the night before pressure got put on him today.

Oh, by the way, TheIrishman passed an item to me, so the redirect must not work on items.

Sure, although we were discussing whether or not the guy would be holding the items to pass, or does he create them by action? If it's an action, only so many people could have done it.

Oh, ok, right, and then TheIrishman supposedly to KY, though TheIrishman didn't say anything about being redirected, is that right? It does seem like TheIrishman would be the most likely of those three, although I don't consider KY and ChopBam proven given that they can be faking the redirect

Why ChopBam and KY?

Then if we consider it's an action, I have this quickly put together list of actions off the top of my head Cat5 - targeted iLTS, TIM, supported by both Chop - N1 actions possibly faked, N2 ??? FRAYDO - targeted Orange, ???, first action supported iLTS - targeted FRAYDO, Shade, second action supported KY - ??? Nodlied - ??? Orange - claims no targets, can't prove TIM - targeted self, self, can't prove Shade - targeted Cat5, KY, supported by both

Sure, and then in that case it would have to be an action, then.

If they are items, then the person distributing them has to be holding them, yes?

No, I don't watch American live-action trash. It may as well all be porn!