There's a definite 4th possibility. The target might have had night BP.
You want me to check you tonight?
Well that's a load of interesting. Yeah I'm definitely not undead. If the only way for scum to kill you is to kill the person you're hiding behind, it's best you hide behind me for more than just that one reason. We have a sort of symbiosis in this case.
Let it be clear though that I'm not neutral like Nodlied's claim; I am flat-out town. Honestly at this point we can probably keep him alive, although if all he's gonna do is hide behind me, I'm not sure what use he'll have to us, since he could potentially kill undead scum if he hides behind them. Do you have any other uses for us, Nodlied?