I think you ought to examine my rebuttal post from this morning:
1) I presume that TheIrishMan and OrangeP47 are the scumteam. Let's start with TheIrishMan. I'd already been hammering away at him for his scum perspective post at the start of this thing. At the same time, iLiketoSnipe is busy suspecting OrangeP47 due to the early hammer suggestion. I was at work so couldn't put more attention to Snipe's read, but I did say I agreed with it.
2) TheIrishMan continued to push for my character flavor--the reason given that "there's only 3 characters that fit the role of a Drunk". I saw this as flawed reasoning, so I tried to get more information out of him.
3) The tipping point: scum feels the pressure is too much between iLiketoSnipe's read on OrangeP47 and my read on TheIrishMan. I claim my character after providing, in my opinion, an excellent post about why I'm town and Irish is wrong. The first quote in that post shows TheIrishMan clearly saying that it doesn't matter which character I claim, I'm still scum. OrangeP47 counterclaims my character a full three minutes after my initial claim. That's plenty of time to have read my post and decided that it was getting to a point of no return.
Hold up your early hammering, I have more to write.