Jump to content

Category 5 Hurricane

VIPs
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    5,037

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    34

  • Donations

    0.00 USD 

 Content Type 

Everything posted by Category 5 Hurricane

  1. Category 5 Hurricane
    Does being checked give you a notification?
  2. Category 5 Hurricane
    Seriously? Why would Nodlied bother doing a force check if Shit? Wouldn't we have found him doing something else? Like, for example, ANYTHING.
  3. Category 5 Hurricane
    I guess unless the Shit have an exception to being forced to not do anything, then Voe can't responsible for that.
  4. Category 5 Hurricane
    Well, until the last night I didn't use any NFAs because I didn't see the need to, and I wanted to preserve FP. Every NFA I had available until the last night was defensive in nature and therefore only useful if I thought I would be attacked. I don't know what an SA is.
  5. Category 5 Hurricane
    I don't think we should shorten the day for VERTi60's convenience anyway. We should only shorten it if we think we've finished the argument. Which, I don't think we will do. ##vote 48hours
  6. Category 5 Hurricane
    You mentioned limiting myself to learning one thing, therefore you must think I have the Intelligence skill. Unless I'm misunderstanding the argument.
  7. Category 5 Hurricane
    I'll repeat to you one more time, TheIrishman, that I never confirmed that I have the Intelligence skill and you have no evidence to suggest that I do.
  8. Category 5 Hurricane
    It isn't as if we're not spending hours thinking on these things ourselves. We're just coming to different conclusions. I don't think it's fair to say "that person is fine with no justification or explanation" when we have been giving explanations. You may not like that you aren't being cleared by people, but I also don't think the argument you're making for yourself is very good. In my case, it's not that I suspect you, it's more that people around you have been eliminated as suspects. But you're right. "It has to be KY or Sunflower" doesn't make sense. That's why I'm not happy with the current situation, because I think it means that one of the cleared players shouldn't be. Perhaps two of them. As it stands, the only two people I don't have pretty good evidence are town are KY and Sunflower, but that doesn't mean someone hasn't faked themselves into that position. Did FRAYDO fake his concern over Orange and his attempt to dodge being killed? Haven't really looked at FRAYDO very much since then. Did he actually do something else? What has he done since? Is Voe actually Sith to begin with and nobody actually taught him Fear? I'll note here that nobody else has claimed such an attack Is Retal making up being contacted by Shade? This stuff about VERTi60 limiting what Shade can say doesn't really fly with me. Is Nodlied's result on TheIrishman wrong? I've got a lot of reasons to suspect TheIrishman, and the result amounts to the only reason why I currently don't. Nodlied and ChopBam are clear to me due to my Mind Melds with them. If OrangeP47 was Shit, Jeod would have known about Shade much earlier and wouldn't have had that public hissy fit. So, in order of current suspicion: Clear, Questionable, Unclear Nodlied OrangeP47 ChopBam FRAYDO Retaliation Sunflower Voe TheIrishman Killing_You
  9. Category 5 Hurricane
    I don't really like how this has turned out. I don't think this game will have only 2 scum, so if my suspect pool is reduced to Killing_You and Sunflower, I should have a 100% hit rate there. (Removing Retaliation because of Shade) But I'm having trouble seeing Sunflower as involved in this. Honestly, I'd even believe a 4-man scum team given the apparent inability for scum to nightkill. I want to ask Shade how does he know that he can only contact people that are clean of the dark side.
  10. Category 5 Hurricane
    I intercepted Nodlied's action result. Nodlied's "light" result on TheIrishman turns me away from TheIrishman. Then ChopBam's first comment indicated to me that ChopBam also knew Nodlied's action result. I see no viable reason for a Shit to take this action or reveal this knowledge, so this turns me away from ChopBam.
  11. Category 5 Hurricane
    Yeah, Irishman, you've marked myself and ChopBam for the wrong action. I did a Learn T1 and a NFA that was worth 30 FP. Regarding Shade's arguments on TheIrishman, I basically agree with all of that. I was going to attack him for pretty much all those things and more. But the night action result I have tells me to drop that case....unless I think that there is something wrong with the result. And I have no reason to think that at this time.
  12. Category 5 Hurricane
    Because I learned a Tier 2 after learning a Tier 1 on N0. That shouldn't be hard to understand. I haven't been using all the FP I can each night because until the last day I thought it was a good idea to conserve FP. That said, I'm glad I did, because I wouldn't have been able to use the Night Force Action I wanted last night if I had spent all I could before.
  13. Category 5 Hurricane
    How do you suggest I should do more learning when I have 20 FP to work with and I just finished the last of the three Tier 1s? I don't know what Nodlied's reasons are, but I do know he has no reason to take the Night Force Action that he did if he's Shit.
  14. Category 5 Hurricane
    VERTi60 already pointed out that the colors were chosen before alignment was assigned. Was Jeod's red?
  15. Category 5 Hurricane
    Right, the result could be misleading or manipulated for reasons we don't know, but for now we probably should proceed as if TheIrishman is clear.
  16. Category 5 Hurricane
    ChopBam didn't want to divulge that much, and since I apparently did the same thing, I won't explain further unless he decides to do so.
  17. Category 5 Hurricane
    I admit I wasn't incredibly confident on my case against you, but the one I had for TheIrishman felt pretty strong and I was going to attack him hard.
  18. Category 5 Hurricane
    I wasn't exactly doubting him, but I had a way to check him and also make sure any info he gathered wasn't limited to just him.
  19. Category 5 Hurricane
    Well that's awesome, now I have to throw out both of my cases. Narrows my suspect pool to Killing_You, Retaliation, Sunflower, but I don't really have anything on any of them.
  20. Category 5 Hurricane
    You did exactly the same thing I did, ChopBam?
  21. Category 5 Hurricane
    *Sigh* I wish Nodlied didn't get that result. That's annoying.
  22. Category 5 Hurricane
    ChopBam and TheIrishman are the remaining Shit. I am perhaps unreasonably confident about this call, but I'll explain as much as I can while still being somewhat concise. You can ask me for details later if you want. First of all, I now feel very confident about these people being Town: FRAYDO - because of his apparent attempt to dodge an potential attack from OrangeP47 OrangeP47 - because of Shade939 Nodlied - because of his investigation role combined with OrangeP47's assurance. Also Jeod wanted to fight him. Voe - because of his reveal of being targeted by...whatever you would call that. I'm left with ChopBam, Killing_You, Retaliation, Sunflower, and TheIrishman as possible suspects. I expect a total of three Shits. The case on ChopBam is an extension of the case on Jeod. Jeod reacted unreasonably negatively to news that was good for town. Jeod's meltdown seemed to have an effect on ChopBam, where ChopBam made one public comment regarding it, "Ugh", and then stayed quiet until near hammer. I'm betting ChopBam did some damage control, but he didn't do it here. It was probably easier to do it in the scum doc. ChopBam has otherwise been noticeably unwilling to make an impact and I've noted at least two not-so subtle attempts to get on my good side for flimsy reasons. The case for TheIrishman doesn't rely on emotions so much, but it does relate to Shade. Based on Jeod's negative reaction and the fact that he did flip Shit, we pretty much know that Shade is a force ghost. We don't need further confirmation. Now, the question I have is, how does one turn into a force ghost, and how common will they be? I don't think it's a case where every dead player or even every dead Jedi will turn to a ghost. There could quickly be too many ways for Jedi to prove themselves. I suspect there will be a specific condition necessary for this to occur, similar to how in Ghost Trick Mafia, a dead player would gain powers if they died while in the same area as a Temsik stone. In this case, I think the trigger will prove to be the player being killed by a Shit. Therefore, TheIrishman is Shit. Obviously these cases aren't final. I can see some room for there to be trickery involving the players I currently trust (particularly Nodlied), and I might have the total number wrong.
  23. Category 5 Hurricane
    ##vote champion Category5 ##vote Sith Jeod Voting myself champion because I want to get a vote in, but I don't want to influence who gets champ between Voe, Orange, or Retal. Off to work.
  24. Category 5 Hurricane
    I guess the main risk comes in when you're facing someone who might have the ability to take you down in one hit.
  25. Category 5 Hurricane
    For the guys who have participated in duels, is there really any advantage in going first? Does it kinda level out after a while?
×
×
  • Create New...