August 15, 20179 yr I have nothing on me once again, and I've told you all the math involved in figuring out true evidence. I don't mind you investigating me, though I think we should check OrangeP47 instead. Besides, as I said before, someone recovered my item for me and passed it to the vault. That person knows where he got it.
August 15, 20179 yr 1 minute ago, VERTi60 said: I should remind you we're not completely clear on Cat5 yet, although he acts town and helps with numbers. But his whole claim about spyglass is somehow getting interesting. Also cat5 claimed Austrian, which according to retal might be the warmongers from (but I'm not completely sold on that since he went after Orange hard yesterday and even before). I don't understand where Retal could've claimed from the evidence that Austrians were part of the Black Hand. The Black Hand were Serbians.
August 15, 20179 yr Just now, VERTi60 said: Well either nationalities do play a role or we have serbians undercovers. Well, the Black Hand had Serbians fighting against themselves, so it would stand to reason that there would be a some good Serbians and some/a bad Serbian{s}.
August 15, 20179 yr Sure? Not exactly. Based on what I've witnessed so far, finding FRAYDO's evidence added 10, finding Chaos's evidence added 10, moving both to the truth box added 6, having Chaos's evidence removed from the vault removed 10. As far as I can tell, nothing else has impacted the numbers. If so, it sure looks like FRAYDO's is true, and Chaos' is not.
August 15, 20179 yr By the way, since Retaliation has confirmed that Chaos is a tracker, and I totally believe Retal is town, this means that neither OrangeP47 nor Chaos is the person who redirected my actions today. Suspects for that are Killing_You and FRAYDO.
August 15, 20179 yr We can now proclaim Fraydo as 100% scum and he's probably the one who switched your action's target.
August 15, 20179 yr The only catch of all this is Cat5's testimony. He's the one that claims there is a thief (nobody else got their stuff stolen?) and now the recent action target switcher (nobody else got their targets switched?). So at some point we need to investigate Cat5 as well but for now we have Fraydo and Orange as biggest suspects.
August 15, 20179 yr 4 minutes ago, TheIrishman said: I don't understand where Retal could've claimed from the evidence that Austrians were part of the Black Hand. The Black Hand were Serbians. I said we could have austro-hungarian warmongers. So they're not part of the black hand, but providing material support in order to bring about a war causing crisis. Remember it was the Austrian government's demands that turned the assassination into a full fledged war. 3 minutes ago, Category 5 Hurricane said: By the way, since Retaliation has confirmed that Chaos is a tracker, and I totally believe Retal is town, this means that neither OrangeP47 nor Chaos is the person who redirected my actions today. Suspects for that are Killing_You and FRAYDO. So your spyglass was stolen earlier, and today someone redirected both the spyglass and the evidence?
August 15, 20179 yr @TheIrishmanpls be a good boy and add to your table the possible roles based on all claims. Let's see who's what.
August 15, 20179 yr That's correct. Somebody passed my SpyGlass into the vault on the previous night. Presumably with the Crowbar. I think someone searched the thief on the previous night and found those items. My SpyGlass when used would automatically send found evidence to the vault, so this action looks similar. The person who did this should be able to confirm my story.
August 15, 20179 yr Just now, Retaliation said: I said we could have austro-hungarian warmongers. So they're not part of the black hand, but providing material support in order to bring about a war causing crisis. Remember it was the Austrian government's demands that turned the assassination into a full fledged war. Exactly. We may have one or two austro/hungarians as warmongers and one or two Serbs as Black Hand. That would make sense. This info could nail the last scum. Just now, Retaliation said: So your spyglass was stolen earlier, and today someone redirected both the spyglass and the evidence? This is something which I don't understand, and it's not making much sense. For now it's all Cat5's testimony until somebody can confirm these actions. Otherwise the bad guys are: Thief, Killer, Target Switcher, and even possibly tracker. We know Jeod was a tracker, so scum could have one too (ey CK? :P)
August 15, 20179 yr 1 minute ago, Category 5 Hurricane said: That's correct. Somebody passed my SpyGlass into the vault on the previous night. Presumably with the Crowbar. I think someone searched the thief on the previous night and found those items. My SpyGlass when used would automatically send found evidence to the vault, so this action looks similar. The person who did this should be able to confirm my story. Exactly we need another testimony to figure this out.
August 15, 20179 yr It looks like the scum teams are coming together. My two suspected team comps are FRAYDO, OrangeP47, and Killing_You or Retaliation, OrangeP47, and Chaos_Knight. Killing_You and Mojoman are the main variables and the ones I'm least confident to pick between. Players Nationality Status Items Evidence Role Town/Scum % Jeod American Town Dead (Typewriter) (Grenade) None Reporter Tracker 100/0 Category 5 Austrian “Suspicious” “Spyglass” Unknown Navy Officer? 80/20 TheIrishman Bosnian Innocent Unknown None that I know of Unknown 100/0 FRAYDO Serbian Suspicious None Black Hand Book (Thief 2) 20/80 Mojoman Serbian “Innocent” Telephone Colt “No Evidence” “Locked till X%” (Thief 1 or 2) 40/60 Chaos_Knight Serbian Suspicious None More Black Hand stuff “Tracker” 50/50 Killing_You Bosnian Unknown (Grenade) Unknown (Thief) 40/60 Verti60 Serbian Innocent None None “Backup” 95/5 OrangeP47 Austrian “Suspicious” “BP Vest” “No Evidence” “Protector” (Killer) 25/75 Retaliation Hungarian “Suspicious” Something Unknown "Roleblocker” 70/30
August 15, 20179 yr I considered the target switcher as thief 2 since he essentially helped steal the items Cat5 dropped, even if they didn't go to him.
August 15, 20179 yr Ah I thought you meant thief suspect n.2 which didn't make sense for some people.
August 15, 20179 yr If cat5 tried to take items himself, I could see a bus driver trying to divert the kill away from cat5 interfereing.
August 15, 20179 yr Wasn't an exact bus like that, though. The SpyGlass was being pocketed by me, but the evidence was moved within the vault. The target of my actions were changed.
August 15, 20179 yr The kill either never happened (scum can't do both actions at once, or is limited either way, or they chose not to do it), or it was blocked by Retal. I don't see a bus happening.
August 15, 20179 yr I've gone from low (worried orange is innocent and kill happens), to high (blocked kill yay!), back to low today (scum knows my role and we're confused again).
August 15, 20179 yr @Category 5 Hurricane @TheIrishman @FRAYDO @Killing You are you ready to claim your roles? It would make the puzzle more complete to determine scum team combinations.
August 15, 20179 yr I have no role besides the one attached to the SpyGlass. I've basically already full claimed, given that I've talked about my SpyGlass and what it does, revealed my nationality, and I've told you every action I've taken.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.