Killing_You

That was a fun time. I'll admit, I had it wrong the whole time. Totally down for a themeless CYOR... though I wonder how Shade will handle the balancing. You kind of implied that you had other ideas in the design doc I left a minor comment a while ago. I'll see you there, then.

Here's where I stand: Right now, I think Orange is scum. I don't like his line of reasoning, as it seems oriented around making his decisions seem right rather than helping town. iLTS, on the other hand, has been very helpful, and his logic seems very pro-Town. That being said, I am sticking to the plan. Tomorrow will be the final debate. I'm very interested in the results.

Thing is, if Voe was Mafia, lynching him would've been a D1 win, so we had to focus our thinking on what would happen if he flipped Town. Answer: No new information. You still would have been either Sane or Naive, and iLikeToSnipe would've still been either Insane or Paranoid. We didn't need a flip, we needed more reports.

I'm still not sold on how. What information did we gain from his death that we didn't from just assuming he was Town? What specific conflicts were resolved? You haven't given direct answers, just vague explanations and deflections. Also, why would scum!KY kill Voe N1 instead of Chop, who got a N0 Mafia report on me? For all we knew at the time, he could've been sane.

I have to bed after posting this, so I won't see the response until tomorrow, but I just have one question. Please elaborate. How was Voe dying bad for Mafia?

I guess I'll officially lend my vote to the extension, then.

Wait, as in going from 24 to 48? If so, I'm abstaining as I'd prefer 24h, but I won't deny people discussion.

I'm down for that.

I also loved the charts. It's done a wonderful job of putting things in perspective.

Ah, I forgot. In that case, I'll investigate you, and you can... I don't know, whatever you feel like doing.

I have to admit, I don't have much of a leg to stand on here. My decision to investigate Voe seems to be coming back to haunt me. So it's down to either Orange or me, eh? Well, in that case, let's do this: We stick to the plan. I'll investigate Orange, he'll investigate me, and the others can take their pick. ##vote NoLynch

Guess we're just waiting on Chop now. See you guys after the read, by the way.

Blech, I made a minor mistake. One second. [PLAYER] [N0 REPORT] [N1 REPORT] [NOT THIS SANITY] Voe iLTS Town rip Paranoid Killing_You ChopBam Town Voe Town Paranoid, Insane iLikeToSnipe Voe Mafia ChopBam Mafia Naive, Sane ChopBam Killing_You Mafia ??? Naive OrangeP47 Voe Town ??? Paranoid, Insane

[PLAYER] [N0 REPORT] [N1 REPORT] [NOT THIS SANITY] Voe iLTS Town rip Paranoid Killing_You ChopBam Town Voe Town Paranoid, Insane iLikeToSnipe Voe Mafia ChopBam Mafia Naive ChopBam Killing_You Mafia ??? Naive OrangeP47 Voe Town ??? Paranoid, Insane

I'm still used to it being 5pm my time (CST). :P

Huh, day started earlier than expected. Unfortunately, I elected to investigate Voe, and I got a Town report.

Just a heads-up, I'll probably be late after day start. I have a table read tonight, and the same goes for Thursday. I will be here to give my report afterwards, or at least the next morning, though.

:P

I'd be fine with that.

We did lynch the GM a long time ago, though. Funnily enough, it was Jeod.

Maybe...? I don't see the need now, but when we get there, I might be open to my mind being changed.

I don't see how that'd help, unless they're a Sane Cop that managed to get Scum N0. Every other circumstance, they'd get another Mafia result from themselves, leaving them with no context as to which one is Insane and which is Paranoid.

I was going to type out the way it plays out and how it would result in us getting more information, but while doing so, I realized that it honestly wouldn't change that much. So, I do concede to your point. ##vote NoLynch Actually, I didn't either.

Generally, I agree, but I think what makes Voe's circumstance unique is that 3/5ths of the players have their N0 cop reports tied to him (Voe, you, and Orange). This feels like the 1 time out of 10.