I won't restate why, just look at my post history, but I firmly believe that ChopBam is scum. He does a good job maintaining his innocence, but I think the rest of us have agreed that he's scum. There's not much point debating it anymore, at least not today.
So, that leaves us with finding the third scum member. Based on how powerful town is and knowing ChopBam's role, I don't see any way that there's only two scum. There's seven of us left and two of those seven are scum. That would mean they need to kill three more of us to win, which puts us at MYLO tomorrow no matter what. So a no lynch is out of the question, we need information.
With ChopBam as the second scum member, we can quickly narrow down who could be the third member.
Mojo is out of the picture, I don't expect scum to have two lynch proofs... Purely in terms of scum read he's in my top four.
FRAYDO has done nothing but help town. He offered to sacrifice himself, he's done a good job scum hunting, and interacting with him in the masonry I get nothing but town reads from him.
KY has also been making posts with good scum hunting content. As far as I'm concerned, his role is confirmed to me through FRAYDO. This and his scum hunting make him town to me.
So that leaves Cat5 and Louis:
Cat5:
Varies his intensity attacking ChopBam based on how "safe" ChopBam currently is
His own posts and scum hunting feel like nebulous statements wrapped in fluff
Picked Shade to boost even though he was the obvious night kill target
We can't validate his ability at all
Louis:
ChopBam has "verified" her role, we otherwise have no way of actually confirming it so far
Not much content D1 and D2, but she claims to have been busy outside of the game
I can't really get any read on her content, but I haven't played many games with her
Currently siding with ChopBam
D3 I didn't have a scum read on Cat5. That all changed when he started defending ChopBam today and making the cases he's made. Looking back at his posts it just feels like "Well who knows? Anybody could be scum! Except maybe not ChopBam." It feels like trying to steer the lynch towards targets of opportunity (i.e. Mojo).
Louis has been a null read up until today for me. She flew under my radar due to the lack of content and the scummy behavior of other players. Looking back on her posts, I can't really see anything up until today that would stand out as scummy behavior, just like Cat5. However, the "meta" of her posts hasn't changed. She still feels like a newer player who's trying to learn.
I can see an alibi for Louis siding with ChopBam, he's just trying to play to her and get a town ally to back him up when it comes to votes. I don't see any alibi for Cat5 outside of being "off his game".
So, I'm keeping my vote on Cat5. I'm convinced that he's the third mafia member and that we should lynch him today.