April 12, 20197 yr Mojoman, mind telling me what you did N1 and N2? And just to entertain the idea, if there is a Thanos, here's the only possibilities left, with KY and Orange being the most provable (web-slinging, and dying potentially revealing) and iLTS being less likely with the whole phasing - leaving Mojo. And iLTS, it's like you completely missed my ability. Still needing Iron Armor and Attunement claimed. Players Char. Role N1 N2 Alignment Cat5 Dr. Strange ? Died Dead Town Shade Yondu Day Vig/Child Stole Prepared Defenses Blocked Chop Nothing Town Irish Stan Lee Unlynchable Watcher Informat Blocked (Visited someone now) Visit Someone Town Mojoman Ultron? Maybe Thanos Some watcher hybrid ability Visited Irish Visited Shade ? iLTS Odin/Loki? Maybe Thanos Car Alarm “Self Targeted” Unknown ? Louis Nebula? ? Nothing? Redirected Orange to Irish Passed Stone to Irish then ChopBam ? ChopBam Drax Lightning Rod Targeted Shade Blocked Lightning Rod Irish Died Town FRAYDO Happy Hogan Roleblocker Roleblocked Irish Didn’t roleblock Irish Unknown ? Orange Nick Fury Maybe Thanos Double Life Some Hybrid ability Soul Stone Roleblocked? “Not Shenanigan related” Passed Soul Stone to Shade Other actions redirected to Irish then to ChopBam ? Killing You Spider-man Maybe Thanos Self Watcher Day Roleblocker “Didn’t target” No one visited Unknown No one visited ? Brigitte Captain Marvel? ? Remove Inhibitor “Not Shenanigan related” Unknown ?
April 12, 20197 yr 1 minute ago, TheIrishman said: And iLTS, it's like you completely missed my ability. Still needing Iron Armor and Attunement claimed. I didn't miss what you claimed, I just don't necessarily believe it right now.
April 12, 20197 yr 4 minutes ago, TheIrishman said: Mojoman, mind telling me what you did N1 and N2? And just to entertain the idea, if there is a Thanos, here's the only possibilities left, with KY and Orange being the most provable (web-slinging, and dying potentially revealing) and iLTS being less likely with the whole phasing - leaving Mojo. It's my turn to need caffeine, but could you rephrase this? I'm having a derp and don't quite get it.
April 12, 20197 yr Just now, OrangeP47 said: It's my turn to need caffeine, but could you rephrase this? I'm having a derp and don't quite get it. What he's saying is that Thanos isn't going to have a non-Thanos ability (i.e. he won't have webshooters). So if he is in the game, we can safely eliminate players from being him based on their provable actions.
April 12, 20197 yr 1 minute ago, iLikeToSnipe said: What he's saying is that Thanos isn't going to have a non-Thanos ability (i.e. he won't have webshooters). So if he is in the game, we can safely eliminate players from being him based on their provable actions. Eh I'm not so sure about that, but I don't really have any traction to argue otherwise.
April 12, 20197 yr Just now, OrangeP47 said: Eh I'm not so sure about that, but I don't really have any traction to argue otherwise. It makes some amount of sense in a game like this (one of my very minor nitpicks for strict flavor based games). Thanos isn't going to be using Iron Man armor, throwing Mjolnir or Stormbreaker around, etc.
April 12, 20197 yr Just now, iLikeToSnipe said: It makes some amount of sense in a game like this (one of my very minor nitpicks for strict flavor based games). Thanos isn't going to be using Iron Man armor, throwing Mjolnir or Stormbreaker around, etc. Well true, but I meant more that if Thanos is about his abilities might not be obvious or obviously named, and he may have secondaries. If you find themeing for a different character, yeah, fair enough, but I'd argue we don't know what Thanos is packing. I'm kind of of the opinion that Thanos isn't in the game, and if we have a collector it's someone else.
April 12, 20197 yr Just now, OrangeP47 said: Well true, but I meant more that if Thanos is about his abilities might not be obvious or obviously named, and he may have secondaries. If you find themeing for a different character, yeah, fair enough, but I'd argue we don't know what Thanos is packing. I'm kind of of the opinion that Thanos isn't in the game, and if we have a collector it's someone else. I don't think anybody can say for certain one way or another if he's in this game. No rules against having him as one of your requested characters. @TheIrishman Honestly though, if somebody picked Thanos and this was my game I'd make them town just to screw with everybody. So while we might be able to determine who couldn't be Thanos it doesn't mean that somebody is Thanos, doesn't mean that Thanos isn't town, and doesn't mean that Thanos' goal is to collect all the stones. It can be a good flavor indicator, but I don't think it's what we should solely scum hunt on. For example, I find your abilities themselves and your actions suspicious. I don't think that you're town and I don't think you're scum, that puts you as TP/neutral. If it turns out you're Thanos, that does not make you more suspicious on its own. It makes you more suspicious given the circumstances of your behavior.
April 12, 20197 yr 3 minutes ago, iLikeToSnipe said: I don't think anybody can say for certain one way or another if he's in this game. No rules against having him as one of your requested characters. Indeed, and Jeod even said multiple people can all be Thanos if they want, but I also just think it's such an obvious choice that nobody went for it because we all want to be unique.
April 12, 20197 yr 5 minutes ago, OrangeP47 said: Indeed, and Jeod even said multiple people can all be Thanos if they want, but I also just think it's such an obvious choice that nobody went for it because we all want to be unique.
April 12, 20197 yr 6 minutes ago, iLikeToSnipe said: Incredibles was such a good movie... I still gotta get around to watching 2.
April 12, 20197 yr 1 minute ago, OrangeP47 said: Incredibles was such a good movie... I still gotta get around to watching 2. Incredibles 2 is good, but not as good as the first one. Definitely worth seeing though. An Incredibles mafia game could also be pretty cool.
April 12, 20197 yr True, being Thanos doesn't necessarily mean that they are Scum. But it does make it all the more suspicious when the only people the could've performed the N1 kill happen to all be potential Thanos players (if there actually is one). iLTS, Mojo, Brigitte, Orange, KY, and Louis (potential killers) iLTS, Mojo, Orange, KY (potential Thanos)
April 12, 20197 yr 6 minutes ago, iLikeToSnipe said: Incredibles 2 is good, but not as good as the first one. Definitely worth seeing though. An Incredibles mafia game could also be pretty cool. It's on netflix (for now), so I can just get around to it whenever though. Just now, TheIrishman said: True, being Thanos doesn't necessarily mean that they are Scum. But it does make it all the more suspicious when the only people the could've performed the N1 kill happen to all be potential Thanos players (if there actually is one). iLTS, Mojo, Brigitte, Orange, KY, and Louis (potential killers) iLTS, Mojo, Orange, KY (potential Thanos) Soul stone was blocking me both nights. Shade can confirm.
April 12, 20197 yr 1 minute ago, OrangeP47 said: Soul stone was blocking me both nights. Shade can confirm. Does it block all actions or just one random action?
April 12, 20197 yr 1 minute ago, iLikeToSnipe said: Does it block all actions or just one random action? I'm guessing all actions, or else it wouldn't have to block Shade's vote as overkill for having no actions. It blocked my night action which is currently a passive so it's pretty strong. I mean I guess the argument can be made it doesn't block the nightkill, but I wouldn't know.
April 12, 20197 yr 1 minute ago, iLikeToSnipe said: Does it block all actions or just one random action? It blocks a single random action on that player, which is probably Orange's only night action it could block. But that probably doens't mean it would block the NK if someone has access to it.
April 12, 20197 yr Just now, OrangeP47 said: I'm guessing all actions, or else it wouldn't have to block Shade's vote as overkill for having no actions. It blocked my night action which is currently a passive so it's pretty strong. I mean I guess the argument can be made it doesn't block the nightkill, but I wouldn't know. Well, if Shade's town confirm role works as most do, he'd have all of his actions removed. I think he even said as such that day.
April 12, 20197 yr Just now, iLikeToSnipe said: Well, if Shade's town confirm role works as most do, he'd have all of his actions removed. I think he even said as such that day. He could vote after being town confirmed though, so it's the stone blocking his vote.
April 12, 20197 yr It replaces one of your actions picked at random, so you can't use that ability till you get rid of the Stone.
April 12, 20197 yr Just now, Shade939 said: It replaces one of your actions picked at random, so you can't use that ability till you get rid of the Stone. And the stone description tells you this? How would Orange not know then?
April 12, 20197 yr Checking my PM, it did NOT say this. Jeod then added on later, in a very causal manner something to the effect that my night action was blocked, and it was the price for wielding the soul stone. I don't want to quote for fear of running afoul of the rules. My guess is he amended it later to actually say it in the stone description.
April 12, 20197 yr Actually, on third inspection.... it does say what Shade says.... I guess, maybe I just didn't pay attention because I got the reminder...
April 12, 20197 yr 2 minutes ago, iLikeToSnipe said: And the stone description tells you this? How would Orange not know then? I can point out at least that Jeod would need to go into more details to explain why I couldn't vote when I had the Stone than most players, who wouldn't run out of actions.
April 12, 20197 yr Author I can make no such comments on the mechanics of the soul stone at this time. I can, however, say that all PMs I sent as of the start of Day 3 are correct and those that were missing information on previous phases had been amended (with the recipient being made aware, of course).
April 12, 20197 yr I mean though, I do have a night action which I was specifically told was not in play, which is kind of lame given it's exact nature, though I don't want to reveal that just yet.
April 12, 20197 yr Author 1 minute ago, Jeod said: I can make no such comments on the mechanics of the soul stone at this time. I can, however, say that all PMs I sent as of the start of Day 3 are correct and those that were missing information on previous phases had been amended (with the recipient being made aware, of course). The language here isn't clear, I'm afraid. In simpler terms, as of the start of Day 3, all PMs were correct and had all the necessary information. I had to be very thorough before sending them out.
April 12, 20197 yr Either way, point is Orange could've still performed the NK. Btw, Fraydo what did you do last night?
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.