Rereading the thread, I'm not too sure why people are town-reading Shade. Asking Cat5 to select a target, not being happy with the unreasonable request, and then proceeding to shoot at Cat5.
A D1 vanilla Town claim is just a tad sus. Given the lethality of the roles ingame, Shade is very lucky to have gotten a Missed result. I think he could have gotten away with the Cat5 kill given their interaction and we would not have lynched him for it.