October 2, 20188 yr Orange simply claimed he was visited, he only knows my role because I gave it out. There's no way you'd know if a cop investigated you. I expected a stronger rebuttal.
October 2, 20188 yr That's a pretty stretched generalization there. But I'm not the guy you're trying to convince.
October 2, 20188 yr Even if he just knows he was visited, you already claimed to not be the cop, and how many possible people who visit do we have. I don't think we'd have a tracker or anything this game, and any variant of that is about all we have left. Stuff being rifled through doesn't sound like a doctor action either.
October 2, 20188 yr Just now, OrangeP47 said: Even if he just knows he was visited, you already claimed to not be the cop, and how many possible people who visit do we have. I don't think we'd have a tracker or anything this game, and any variant of that is about all we have left. Stuff being rifled through doesn't sound like a doctor action either. He doesn't need to convince them that he was visited by a cop, he needs to convince them he was visited period. Did you two think that one through?
October 2, 20188 yr Author 5 hours ago, iLikeToSnipe said: ##vote Jeod 1 hour ago, Jeod said: ##vote OrangeP47 Votes counted. CVC: Jeod voted OrangeP47 OrangeP47 voted nobody Nodlied voted nobody Shade939 voted nobody TheIrishMan voted Jeod iLikeToSnipe voted nobody Sunflower voted Jeod Jeod has the majority for the lynch (3 votes). WARNING! 1 more vote for Jeod will cause a HAMMER! Time Left: 5h 16m
October 2, 20188 yr Looks like Sunflower gave you a gift. You get to cause an early hammer after all.
October 2, 20188 yr 1 minute ago, Jeod said: He doesn't need to convince them that he was visited by a cop, he needs to convince them he was visited period. Did you two think that one through? Considering I'm not in contact with Irish, we're not doing any joint thinking
October 2, 20188 yr 1 minute ago, Killing_You said: Votes counted. CVC: Jeod voted OrangeP47 OrangeP47 voted nobody Nodlied voted nobody Shade939 voted nobody TheIrishMan voted Jeod iLikeToSnipe voted nobody Sunflower voted Jeod Jeod has the majority for the lynch (3 votes). WARNING! 1 more vote for Jeod will cause a HAMMER! Time Left: 5h 16m You missed Snipe's vote in the CvC despite quoting it, btw.
October 2, 20188 yr Author Just now, Jeod said: You missed Snipe's vote in the CvC despite quoting it, btw. Shyte. I need my coffee. CVC: Jeod voted OrangeP47 OrangeP47 voted nobody Nodlied voted nobody Shade939 voted nobody TheIrishMan voted Jeod iLikeToSnipe voted Jeod Sunflower voted Jeod Jeod has the majority for the lynch (3 votes). WARNING! 1 more vote for Jeod will cause a HAMMER! Time Left: 5h 12m
October 2, 20188 yr Tch. This is what overreactions get you. Counterclaiming a player just after they go to sleep, allowing others to pile up the votes for an early hammer. Have you any decency?
October 2, 20188 yr Just now, Jeod said: Tch. This is what overreactions get you. Counterclaiming a player just after they go to sleep, allowing others to pile up the votes for an early hammer. Have you any decency? Honestly, if you were innocent, I'd think you'd be flipping out more.
October 2, 20188 yr Just now, OrangeP47 said: Honestly, if you were innocent, I'd think you'd be flipping out more. Neither of the two players who need to change their minds are online right now. There's no point in "flipping out".
October 2, 20188 yr 40 minutes ago, TheIrishman said: Someone rifled through my stuff, generally that means a cop. To be fair, I’m going to point out that this basically means you have an ability similar to a Watcher since you can largely tell what actions targeted you during the night phase then and it’s confirmed by the GM and doesn’t actaully make you a very vanilla role actaully. Also, I’m really surprised no one has spoken up about Category 5 targeting last night them by now...
October 2, 20188 yr Just now, Shade939 said: To be fair, I’m going to point out that this basically means you have an ability similar to a Watcher since you can largely tell what actions targeted you during the night phase then and it’s confirmed by the GM and doesn’t actaully make you a very vanilla role actaully. Also, I’m really surprised no one has spoken up about Category 5 targeting last night them by now... I made that comment
October 2, 20188 yr Author 2 minutes ago, iLikeToSnipe said: ##unvote Vote counted. CVC: Jeod voted OrangeP47 OrangeP47 voted nobody Nodlied voted nobody Shade939 voted nobody TheIrishMan voted Jeod iLikeToSnipe voted nobody Sunflower voted Jeod Jeod has the majority for the lynch (2 votes). Time Left: 4h 54m
October 2, 20188 yr 4 minutes ago, OrangeP47 said: I made that comment I think I’ll be lazy and take your word for it, since apparantly I completely missed it.
October 2, 20188 yr Just now, Shade939 said: I think I’ll be lazy and take your word for it, since apparantly I completely missed it. Well I didn't say Cat 5 targetted me, if that's what you meant. My comment was that what Irish said didn't sound like a doctor visit message.
October 2, 20188 yr So @OrangeP47, did you miss the opportunity to early hammer because KY's CvC confused you, or are you just unsure of what other factors could stop you when I flip town?
October 2, 20188 yr For the record, while I'm tempted, it's rude to do so without consensus. I have an eye doctor apointment I need to leave for in about 30 minutes, and errands after that, but once I get back it will be much closer to deadline and I'll be much more agreeable towards ending things early, as most people will have had time to weigh in by then.
October 2, 20188 yr Just now, OrangeP47 said: Well I didn't say Cat 5 targetted me, if that's what you meant. My comment was that what Irish said didn't sound like a doctor visit message. Ok, so you didn’t say what I was saying at all then... There’s two pieces of information that also need to be determined concerning Category 5’s death based on what we know so far. 1. If Category 5 self targeted. 2. If anyone else visited Orange last night other than Jeod.
October 2, 20188 yr Just now, Shade939 said: Ok, so you didn’t say what I was saying at all then... There’s two pieces of information that also need to be determined concerning Category 5’s death based on what we know so far. 1. If Category 5 self targeted. 2. If anyone else visited Orange last night other than Jeod. I highly doubt he self-targeted, given that he died, and in a game like this I don't think there'd be an ability to bypass the doctor.
October 2, 20188 yr Allthough in all fairness, it is a lower priority than the Orange vs. Jeod debate still.
October 2, 20188 yr 1 minute ago, Shade939 said: Allthough in all fairness, it is a lower priority than the Orange vs. Jeod debate still. Well there's always future discussion. We only get 1 out of 2 scum today no matter who we vote for.
October 2, 20188 yr Just now, OrangeP47 said: Well there's always future discussion. We only get 1 out of 2 scum today no matter who we vote for. Can’t speak up tomorrow if your dead tonight though.
October 2, 20188 yr 1 minute ago, Shade939 said: Can’t speak up tomorrow if your dead tonight though. I meant we can talk about it now Discussion ABOUT the future.
October 2, 20188 yr Speaking of the future, if Irish is being truthful about being visited by a cop, their sanity is still unknown. It's probably best not to drag them out into the arena just yet.
October 2, 20188 yr Here's a scenario for you to see why I'm against a cop coming out: Irish is scum, but a cop got a town result on him. The cop is insane. I'm lynched, I flip town. The cop is nightkilled. Irish is lynched, the cop is confirmed insane. Another town is killed. You're now down to 1 scum and 3 town. Naturally, Orange should be lynched. However, what if KY did goof and assign a character twice? Perhaps he's nightkilled and it's realized the dawn of the final day. 3 town, 1 scum. 25% and no information. I would prefer a cop try to stay alive in this case.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.