FRAYDO

Yes. No. Maybe. Either way, I don't like the tone of it. This seems like a solid plan to me, given how today turned out. Irish was lynched and now Shade can proceed with his test. 'course, Shade also believes this could happen too! If the cooldown claim is true, Category 5 should not be able to do that! How can this night possibly go wrong? And yet, Shade is already posting a eulogy noting an inability to role block Category 5. In what way would this be possible? In light of your uncanny knowledge of these items and how they apparently fit into the picture here, have we not determined that Jeod died with those two items? On this topic too, there was that potential slip of a third item from Shade. What if that's the item Mafia needs to succeed tonight? The item that may or may not be in Shade's possession. All of this is very curious. @ Louis it's up to you it seems! No pressure at all! You just need to make the right decision! You haven't! We're behind schedule!

Huh. I practically ignored the thread because I was confident Irish was scum and liked seeing Shade and Category 5 hash it out. Unfortunate. Predicting tonight's death, are we?

Interesting. @ ChopBam r u 100% Vanilla?

I have re-read through the thread and checked Ctrl+F "hunter" on each page. You have never told anyone earlier here about Hunter Seeker Drones.

Seems too convoluted for my liking. A self-target NK to be swapped, only for this plan to fail because you were jailed and therefore protected. Noted. Re-reading, it appears Jeod has been careful not to do so. This isn't mutual though. Category 5 had accused Irish of being suspect #1. And we know that suspect #2 was right on the money with Jeod's reveal. At the end of the day too, Category 5 left his vote on Jeod. A Jeod-Category 5 scum team would likely have played this better and got the vote pushed onto Irish instead. We could always look back into this final CVC and see if there's something new we can learn or something that we may have missed earlier.

I'm not sure I'm comfortable yet with a vote on Category5. Seeing the order of events, this is true. Of course, this came with suspicion as to how Jeod found that out. This brings me back to Irish supposedly being that investigate role that you believe him to be, Shade. Soon afterward though, Category 5 did go ahead and roll with it. I wonder if he was lying after all, but as Town!Category 5 this could have been to goad mafia into killing him rather than our claimed Jailer. If Irish is indeed that investigative role, this may explain Jeod's knowledge other than him piecing it together himself. I wouldn't think Jeod would carelessly slip like that. Another point (and emphasized) -- I don't see a Scum!Category 5 bussing one of his own Scum teammates. The whole discussion revolving around Jeod and his story constantly changing was something we did nail. Being the vocal person that he is, it did generate a feeling that Category 5 was able to put into words for me. Additionally, we have today's confusion around Irish's claimed nightly activities. Seeing as we are lacking confirmation from ChopBam on this, this does not confidently place Irish as visiting Chop after all. If anything, this may be his best alibi given the circumstances. You may keep your vote on Category 5, Shade, as I would like to hear him speak up and report. I will be sticking to Irishman myself. ##vote TheIrishman

Anyone else having trouble posting on the forums? I'm logged in on this current page but when I visit the other pages in this thread I get logged out. I noticed it when I was quoting the posts above.

The jail claim seems to match up with Louis' later statement. I would suspect ChopBam as Jeod's scum partner but Irish here is confirming him as Town. My suspicion of him was based on not believing his vanilla claim. However, this may clear ChopBam. Seeing that Retaliation was jailed yet there was still an attempt on Louis' life, I believe we can rule out Retaliation as scum. Scum suspects at this time: Irishman - "Confirming" ChopBam as Town and supposedly left an item for him at the same time. Category5 - No report as of yet.

Call it nitpicking, but I find it unusual naming Jeod as himself and not as Bifar Skarsgard in this context. Anyway,

I don't quite have the answer for the late Bifar Skarsgard as to who his partner may have been, but I like to think our remaining scum suspect has been narrowed significantly with today's reveal. I also think it likely we'll all be here tomorrow, so see you all then!

Throughout this day, I have not liked how Jeod has changed his stories. On the first report, Jeod has claimed he passed his item. No interruptions or inconveniences to note. Stating that Louis should outright come out and say what they have done, but Jeod did not make such a report either. Louis claims they have blocked Jeod, which makes sense in this current case. And now the story is Jeod attempted to pass his item, now knowing he may have been blocked. But later into the conversation with other things coming to light, the revised story is now that his PM says he was jailed. I can understand not wanting to come out with it as the first report because of all the immediate suspicion that would get, but I don't like how much it took for this claim to come out. I am not particularly a fan of the many vanilla roles claimed at this point either, but that's another discussion. ##vote Jeod

It still will be. This was fixed for everyone else but your client specifically will still crash. <3

Sure.

He never stated who he attempted to pass it to.

It can't be that easy, could it?

I have no reason to believe otherwise unless you think to read even further into the OP. If you want to note that, then it may open the possibility for House Harkonnen to have an action to eliminate their foes. This does not change my stance on the matter.

I would believe my earlier point of there not being a daykill role stands in light of that thought.

As entertaining as it may be for Shade to be shot at, I would think that Jeod is lying. Voting is our only action per the OP, and any items in this game would have passives when activated. I don't think there's a daykill role here.

Snooze

Unless triplets! Quadruplets! Or Pentaplets??? I don’t think that last one exists.

Taken by Shai-Hlud or however you spell it.

Bold of Shade to claim Vanilla Town and also bait a NK.l, even if it’s as silly as claiming an Atomic Bomb. I didn’t realize Dune had those! I suppose two Vanillas isn’t too far-fetched, even in this small game. I’m wary of the claim but have no other leads. ##vote NoLynch

Twinsies! Unless one of us may be lying!