Games [GAME OVER] Tiberian Sun: Reborn Mafia II

[Shade939]

Since, a netural/TP dieing still preserves the Town to Mafia ratio for their victory condition. Only thing that changes that is killing Mafia.

[Category 5 Hurricane]

9 minutes ago, Shade939 said:

Tell, you what, I'll prove it with the same certainty that you're not scum.

Day 8 2

Night 7 2

Day 6 2

Night 5 2

Day 4 2

Night 3 2

 

[Jeod]

I would love to know why each player who has their vote on Shade, has their vote on Shade.

[Category 5 Hurricane]

Added the missing numbers for you.

[Jeod]

Just now, Category 5 Hurricane said:

Added the missing numbers for you.

Especially you, who usually wants people to answer questions asked of them instead of things being answered for them.

[Jeod]

It'll probably miss anyway.

##shoot Category 5 Hurricane

[Category 5 Hurricane]

4 minutes ago, Shade939 said:

Or that the TP won't die before D4 also.

You think there are two mafia. The game would end sooner than your template if there were three.

[Killing_You]

Just now, Jeod said:

It'll probably miss anyway.

##shoot Category 5 Hurricane

@Jeodshoots at @Category 5 Hurricane, but misses!

Hammer time.

[Shade939]

Just now, Category 5 Hurricane said:

You think there are two mafia. The game would end sooner than your template if there were three.

TP has to stay alive for the game to end on a day phase. And no day kills or extra NKs.

[Category 5 Hurricane]

I'm going to need a new F5 key.

[Killing_You]

NIGHT ONE

At the end of a long, tense day, the base personnel agree that the best course of action is to lynch Shade. A quick search of his belongings in the aftermath, however, prove his loyalty posthumously.

Shade939, the GDI Light Infantry, has been lynched!

With no leads as to who may be hostile, they prepare for a long night...

PLAYER	VOTE
@Jeod	NoLynch
@Retaliation	Shade939
@ChopBam
@Anon_Kat	Shade939
@OrangeP47	Shade939
@Louis	NoLynch
@Category 5 Hurricane	Shade939
@Shade939	NoLynch
@Mojoman	NoLynch
@FRAYDO	Shade939
LEAD	Shade939- 5/6-HAMMER

Day 2 begins in 24 hours. Please try to send in your actions in 1 hour prior to daystart.

As usual, 2 night posts per player.

[Jeod]

I'm very suspicious of a Cat5/Orange 2/3 team. That was the strangest, most unexpected behavior from you two to tunnel Shade on the first day for pretty much nothing.

[OrangeP47]

I start making dinner 5 minutes early cause it's just a bunch of phase talk and I don't think anything is gonna happen and that happens.... c'mon guys...

Also, before I forget:  I'M HAVING POLISH SAUSAGE AND MASH POTATOS AND GREEN BEANS.

On a more serious note:  Jeod, I feel like your analysis is very 101 tier and if you were actually trying you'd be doing better.  A lot of the accusations you level at us could be turned around at you, just for defense tunnel instead of an agro tunnel.  It would work towards the conclusion that you knew Shade would flip town and wanted the cred when we all made a mistake and killed him in our ignorance.

[ChopBam]

If Orange and Cat5 were a team, they'd probably keep Shade alive for the chaos.

[Jeod]

11 minutes ago, OrangeP47 said:

I start making dinner 5 minutes early cause it's just a bunch of phase talk and I don't think anything is gonna happen and that happens.... c'mon guys...

Also, before I forget:  I'M HAVING POLISH SAUSAGE AND MASH POTATOS AND GREEN BEANS.

On a more serious note:  Jeod, I feel like your analysis is very 101 tier and if you were actually trying you'd be doing better.  A lot of the accusations you level at us could be turned around at you, just for defense tunnel instead of an agro tunnel.  It would work towards the conclusion that you knew Shade would flip town and wanted the cred when we all made a mistake and killed him in our ignorance.

Deflection. You’ve yet to answer why you voted him. I believe you said it was a “safe lynch”?

[OrangeP47]

1 minute ago, Jeod said:

Deflection. You’ve yet to answer why you voted him. I believe you said it was a “safe lynch”?

I mean, you could just pay attention in the thread, I rue wasting my second night post on this, but I'll lay out all the reasons.

1)  I'm vehemently against no lynch (in non CYOR games)

2)  Recall early on (like the first *real life* day of the game) when I called Shade out for several meta inconsistencies.  He wasn't sitting right with me the entire phase, even if I was joking it up about it.  It was half joking/half serious.

3)  His shot wasn't the best.  Now you may say, but Orange, he shot the guy you were casing/voting.  Yeah, he did.  But look at how he handled it.  Look at the WAY he did it.  I was gonna make a separate point for it, but really it goes here, think about this in conjuncture with the fact that he pretty quickly pivoted to no lynch after his shot failed instead of voting Anon.  Yeah, we now know Shade was town, but he wasn't acting town.

2 and 3 means Shade is a valid target in my book, 1 means if the trains are no lynch and someone else, I'm going to try to steer it away from no lynch, assuming the other train is not someone I'm feeling is town, which again, points 2 and 3.  This is entirely consistent with everything I do.

[Mojoman]

Oh jeeze I thought we had another day until N1.

[Mojoman]

I knew nolynch was good D1 though

[Retaliation]

I've thought hard and long about this and I have no regrets.

[Killing_You]

DAY TWO

The sun rises once again. The base personnel realize one of their own is missing, only to find their body a short distance away.

Category 5 Hurricane, as Umagon, was killed!

Day 2 ends in 48 hours.

[Jeod]

Hey riot trooper. Must've been a tad on the scummy side to you on D1.

[Retaliation]

Are you claiming roleblocked?

[Jeod]

Just now, Retaliation said:

Are you claiming roleblocked?

Yep. I got restrained.

[Retaliation]

Well if this claim holds up Jeod couldn't have killed cat5.

Is this a repeat of rebarn 1 mafia where scum killed off the other town on the D1 train?

[Retaliation]

Those thoughts are somewhat separate btw. I'm aware scum Jeod could have had his partner kill Cat5.

[Jeod]

1 minute ago, Retaliation said:

Well if this claim holds up Jeod couldn't have killed cat5.

Is this a repeat of rebarn 1 mafia where scum killed off the other town on the D1 train?

I’d expect an experienced scum player to off myself or Cat5.

Regarding the kill, I usually prefer to keep Cat5 alive when I’m scum so I can enjoy the game more.

[Retaliation]

Just now, Jeod said:

I’d expect an experienced scum player to off myself or Cat5.

Regarding the kill, I usually prefer to keep Cat5 alive when I’m scum so I can enjoy the game more.

Scum is obviously learning from Orange and I's expert performance during the CYOR except no night actions game.

[Retaliation]

Wait the lesson from that game was never target Cat5 with any night actions so that can't be right.

[OrangeP47]

[OrangeP47]